Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

rp516

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 27, 2018
19
1
Hi,
Been trying to browse various threads on here for anyone who’s had a similar issue and had it resolved already and couldn’t find anything.

About 10 days ago or so I was using my computer normally when suddenly it froze and wouldn’t let me move the mouse, type, etc. so I manually shut it down thinking I could restart. Once I did, I got the continual spinning circle on the startup screen until the Apple logo changed to a circle with a line thru it.

There was a similar situation thread in the desktop section that I went through and tried following all the solutions people had found in there: running disk utility (no problems come up) and then when I try to reinstall OS X (Mid-2010 MBP), it only gives me Recovery HD as my option to install OS X (no Mac HD option) and the Recovery HD is locked.
After some discussion there it was concluded that the hard drive likely died (I connected an external hd and tried installing OS X on there and it worked perfectly fine) and would need replacement, which I’m fine with doing.

When running disk utility on “Macintosh HD”, verify/repair disk on that option, gave the following error:

Invalid node structure. The volume could not be verified completely.

Error: Disk Utility can’t repair this disk....disk, and restore your backed

I mainly care about getting several files off my computer, and after that have no problem wiping it clean and starting it like factory settings .. from what little I understand, it seemed like most solutions people found in that thread required wiping all data beforehand (I don’t have a backup to go back on) and so was wondering if there’s a solution where that isn’t necessary (or at least let’s you into the computer long enough to pull files off it? Before having to wipe it clean)

I found the program MacDriver online, so got that and was able to just connect my (old) harddrive to another computer and pull off about 80% of files.
A lot of the larger size files, I wasn’t able to bc it would give me an error that the said the file location was incorrect and no longer in that place that it was.... (though from appearances it was??)

I was looking at buying a new HD and was told that after installing that it may bring the computer back to being usable and can reinstall OS X on it. I went to buy one and try this out but was talked out of it from the salesperson who said I can’t put a 1 TB drive in that older version of computer, and the max would be 500GB ?? .. which seemed odd because from what everything I’ve seen online, people buy the 250GB one and upgrade it however they want?
 
Sounds like you had a hard disk failure.
Disk Utility cannot repair the drive it starts from. That said, the drive may not be completely salvageable.
The drives in these models are easily replaced, as long as you have the correct tools. Check ifixit.com for detailed step-by-step.
You can replace your drive with a 1TB. I strongly recommend an SSD - way more resistant to shock and vibration, and your system will perform better than new. 500GB may have been the largest size available from Apple when purchased as new...
 
  • Like
Reactions: rp516
Sounds like you had a hard disk failure.
Disk Utility cannot repair the drive it starts from. That said, the drive may not be completely salvageable.
The drives in these models are easily replaced, as long as you have the correct tools. Check ifixit.com for detailed step-by-step.
You can replace your drive with a 1TB. I strongly recommend an SSD - way more resistant to shock and vibration, and your system will perform better than new. 500GB may have been the largest size available from Apple when purchased as new...

Great thanks for the confirmation on being able to boost the size!
It was at Best Buy.. I had a 1TB in hand when the sales guy said that, so I wasn’t sure

USB enclosure the best way to retrieve files off the bad drive? Or is there a better /another method more reliable to do so?
[doublepost=1537166648][/doublepost]
It could also be a failed sata hard drive cable.
Thanks! I had heard this from another thread as well... figured if the drive replacement didn’t work, that’d be my next step
 
Drive enclosures are one way to do this, but requires a bit more work to get the drive in, and then later, out.
Many people use drive docks for ad-hoc drive mounting. Other use simple cable harness assemblies. Best to get one rated for USB3. I use all 3, but prefer the dock.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rp516
Drive enclosures are one way to do this, but requires a bit more work to get the drive in, and then later, out.
Many people use drive docks for ad-hoc drive mounting. Other use simple cable harness assemblies. Best to get one rated for USB3. I use all 3, but prefer the dock.

Excellent, thank you! Will check out a dock as the drive enclosure I bought doesn't even fit the HD from my MBP o_O

--

Are there any reliable SSDs besides the Samsung 860 ones? I was hoping to spend a bit less... but all the cheaper alternatives have countless reviews of crashing after a few months of use. If the Samsung one is much more reliable as it sounds like is the case, then may just fork out the extra cash for it .. but if there's an alternative that I'm overlooking that would be useful to know :)
 
Are there any reliable SSDs besides the Samsung 860 ones?
I think people have had good experiences with "brand name" SSDs, at least with general computing workloads. Crucial, WD, SanDisk, and others. I've had product from non-Samsung SSDs working for years in various laptops, and my 2009 cMP.
 
Last edited:
I've had good results with Adata, Crucial, Corsair, Patriot, and Intel.

I think people have had good experiences with "brand name" SSDs, at least with general computing workloads. Crucial, WD, SanDisk, and other. I've had product from non-Samsung SSDs working for years in various laptops, and my 2009 cMP.


Great, thank you both for the replies!

Went to the store intending to buy a Samsung 500GB but they had a SanDisk ssd larger capacity for the same price so went with that

Just finished installing and everything works great so far!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.