Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Spaceboi Scaphandre

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 8, 2022
3,414
8,113
So Apple recently dropped the 2022 Holiday Gift Guide store page (where for once they actually advertise Macs wooooooo!) and well...

holiday-hero-new-202211
holiday-hero-gifts-202211
holiday-hero-picks-202211


So with...whatever the hell these abominations are, I think it's time we had a discussion about Memojis

If you've known me, I have an absolute deep hatred for Memojis (and the uncanny corporate emoji avatar style in general.) In terms of avatar creation, Memojis are incredibly limiting. So many headshapes look the same and they all make the same damn face. Just looking at one sets off mixed feelings, especially when they make those hideous smiles like above.

Remember Mark Zuckerberg's VR selfie, and how ugly his avatar was that it was mocked and ridiculed across the entire internet that it caused Meta stock to tank?

FaV_ZzEWQAAtU2S


That's the feeling I get every time I see a memoji. There's the thing: In VR, I can just turn these ugly avatars off and go into apps where they're not supported so I can ignore them entirely. I can't ignore memojis because everywhere I go there's always someone using them as a profile pic. Even my own family members use the damn things as their iMessage pictures.

In contrast to Memojis, allow me to present the Nintendo Mii:

Screenshot_2016-09-01_10.44.24.0.0.png


Miis are what Memojis should have been. Miis keep it simple and cute looking and aren't uncanny like Memojis are. By keeping it simple they have a lot more options for customization, different shapes, different eyes, different hairs, and they only got better overtime. You could pretty much recreate whoever you wanted with Miis as people made Peter Griffin and Hank Hill as Miis

dbmfmhs-ead6f01e-4d53-4e7d-bb5c-cffbb854e95a.png
dbn7cnb-0795f73d-be3e-42b0-b4c3-27b06f22e352.png


Pretty difficult to do that with Memojis. Hell with the release of Miitopia on Nintendo Switch Mii 2.0 came with it, and the Mii creation got even better with even more options that even more characters were recreated with hilarious results, being able to use new custom face texturing to use new art styles. This is why the Miis have had such longevity ever since the Nintendo Wii in 2006, while Memojis and the other corporate uncanny avatars are viewed with disgust by the general public.

So bottom line, Memojis need changing. Cut back on the uncanny 3D floating heads and make them more simplistic with more customization options. Apple's great for simplicity, so make the avatars simple as well so they don't hurt my eyes every time I look at them.
 
Interesting take. I can't say I agree with anything you said.

Apple has always been known for flashy animations. Simple? Sure. As in not too many products, not too many extra things and more focus on the products they do make well. Simple in terms of animations, looks, and not too many details? Yeah that's not what Apple is simple at. They love their fancy designs.

Memojis look 1000x better than those 2007 Nintendo things. I loved my Wii, but it's 2022 and this is Apple. No they should not be perfect round oval heads with 2D lines drawn on them. If anything memojis are a totally extra and non necessary thing, and if Apple didn't like them they'd be more likely to scrap them than to make them uglier.

Part of me genuinely cannot tell if you're joking with the example of Miis you posted as "not looking uncanny".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Slartibart
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.