Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Six0Four

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Mar 27, 2020
1,159
1,910
Just curious what y'all thought.

Think the Plus will outsell the Mini, or is the Mini fan base too strong?
 
I would bet a month’s salary that the plus will sell more. Most people want a larger phone with longer battery life.

The whole mini fiasco was because Apple miscalculated the market. There was a small but very vocal group of people that wanted a smaller iPhone. The problem they didn’t think about battery life. If the battery is almost half the size, it’s going to have a much shorter battery life even with a smaller screen. Perhaps the future is a mini size phone that folds out to a larger phone but currently the technology just isn’t here. Yes I know there are folding phones but they’re not ready for primetime.
 
I feel like the Plus will sell better and many people (Baby Boomers such as my mom for instance) want a bigger screen and don't really care about/want the Pro features.
My folks love their iPads over their phones and they travel a ton as well. At home, iPads…on the road, iPads. Phones that are too big are harder to hold and still don’t provide enough screen real estate so just a waste for them. 6.1” phones are as big as they’ll go and they hold onto them forever.
 
Fundamentally, the 14 Plus sells based on the same principles that made XR/11 successful.

Big display
Great battery life
Affordable price

Most people just don’t see the need for a third camera or pill, even if it costs $200 more.
Problem is if you’re willing to give up .6” screen and fork over $100 more you’ll get a vastly superior iPhone Pro. I bet the Plus goes on sale quick as Apple botched the launch and most people probably forgot it existed.
 
Problem is if you’re willing to give up .6” screen and fork over $100 more you’ll get a vastly superior iPhone Pro. I bet the Plus goes on sale quick as Apple botched the launch and most people probably forgot it existed.

Most people don’t exchange large display for a third camera. It just doesn’t work that way.

Half the battle is explaining what telephoto is in the first place. You don’t need someone to explain how a bigger display or longer batter life translates to better usability.
 
Most people don’t exchange large display for a third camera. It just doesn’t work that way.
Exactly. Those that are more into cameras are going to get the Pro. If you know you want the best camera and want the larger screen, then those people are probably going to go for the Pro Max.

The people that want a basic iPhone but just want a larger screen are going to go for the Plus. It’s kind of like cars. For every model there’s the top of the line editions and then there’s the midrange models. Some people want leather seats and a heated steering wheel while others just want a car that drives but also has power windows.
 
I think most people here are right, the Plus will sell more but I think it being released weeks after the 14 and 14 pro that will hurt it's sales. Lot's of people couldn't wait and ended up buying another version I feel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
I would bet a month’s salary that the plus will sell more. Most people want a larger phone with longer battery life.

The whole mini fiasco was because Apple miscalculated the market. There was a small but very vocal group of people that wanted a smaller iPhone. The problem they didn’t think about battery life. If the battery is almost half the size, it’s going to have a much shorter battery life even with a smaller screen. Perhaps the future is a mini size phone that folds out to a larger phone but currently the technology just isn’t here. Yes I know there are folding phones but they’re not ready for primetime.
Battery life on the 12 mini was so so. Anyone who isn’t getting through a full day with the battery life on a 13 mini should probably reevaluate how much time they're spending on their phone.
 
Battery life on the 12 mini was so so. Anyone who isn’t getting through a full day with the battery life on a 13 mini should probably reevaluate how much time they're spending on their phone.
I think battery life on the mini is enough for someone who doesn’t use their phones very much. We can all argue that people spend too much time on their phones but that’s just a fact of life. People are not going to buy a phone with a shorter battery life because of that. People drink too much soda, but that doesn’t mean they’re going to buy an 8 ounce soda versus the 20 ounce soda.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Techwatcher and OJK
I would bet a month’s salary that the plus will sell more. Most people want a larger phone with longer battery life.

The whole mini fiasco was because Apple miscalculated the market. There was a small but very vocal group of people that wanted a smaller iPhone. The problem they didn’t think about battery life. If the battery is almost half the size, it’s going to have a much shorter battery life even with a smaller screen. Perhaps the future is a mini size phone that folds out to a larger phone but currently the technology just isn’t here. Yes I know there are folding phones but they’re not ready for primetime.
The solution is to make the mini fat enough to lay flat. Killing the idiotic camera bump would make the mini the top seller. How does apple keep doubling down on this insane uneven back design? Kill the bump, add back battery, and make all iPhones 1 handed again! Or not. The ultra finally made the watch seem viable to me, so I hope to rarely carry my phone anymore after my ultra finally gets in. I’d carry an iPhone if it wasn’t so big and unwieldy, but I’m in the minority who’d prefer to still have an iPhone 1-5 sized device with a modern motherboard and display.
 
I think most people here are right, the Plus will sell more but I think it being released weeks after the 14 and 14 pro that will hurt it's sales. Lot's of people couldn't wait and ended up buying another version I feel.
I don’t think so. I think there are two groups of people that buy phones. One are the tech nerds here that must have the latest and greatest on launch day and the other are just average non techy people.

The techy people are not going to buy anything less than the best most expensive model out there so the plus isn’t even on their radar.

Your normal non techy people are going to buy a phone based on when their carrier has it available for them. Most of the time that means after they finish paying off their current model or when the trade in is available. I guarantee you your average person is likely aware that Apple released a new phone, but they couldn’t tell you exactly when it came out.
 
The solution is to make the mini fat enough to lay flat. Killing the idiotic camera bump would make the mini the top seller. How does apple keep doubling down on this insane uneven back design? Kill the bump, add back battery, and make all iPhones 1 handed again! Or not. The ultra finally made the watch seem viable to me, so I hope to rarely carry my phone anymore after my ultra finally gets in. I’d carry an iPhone if it wasn’t so big and unwieldy, but I’m in the minority who’d prefer to still have an iPhone 1-5 sized device with a modern motherboard and display.
That would solve the battery life problem of the mini, but I still don’t think most people would go with the smaller screen. Younger people want a larger screen to display more content and older people want a larger screen because they can’t see the small screen 😂

If you took the Plus or Max size iPhone and made it level with the camera bump that would make it very heavy. I don’t think people would like it as much. They already have more than one day of battery life, so carrying double the weight weight wouldn’t be beneficial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OJK
My partner has an iPhone 12 pro max, which she chose rather than a 13 pro max because she needed the bigger screen, but could care less about camera specs yet does care about a lower monthly payment with the carrier. I don't know if she ever uses telephoto either, so chances are good her next phone will be something like the 14 plus. If anything, the 14 plus may reduce sales of 14 pro max.

ETA: she's uninterested in Pro Motion, also, because she doesn't play games on it.
 
Last edited:
I think the 14 Plus is a great phone and will sell much better due to size and battery. However, it’s priced too high, deliberately to drive people to the Pro models. It should have started at $749.

How do you expect it to start at $749 when the regular iPhone starts at $799 😂😂

I think it’s just different levels. It’s $200 cheaper than the Pro version just like the regular iPhone. People still buy it all the time even though for $200 extra, they could buy the Pro. They don’t need or want the Pro so why spend $200 for no reason.

I think people here are looking at it from a techy standpoint where why would you want less of a phone. I mean can we get the Ultra Pro Super Max for $1999
 
My partner has an iPhone 12 pro max, which she chose rather than a 13 pro max because she needed the bigger screen, but could care less about camera specs yet does care about a lower monthly payment with the carrier. I don't know if she ever uses telephoto either, so chances are good her next phone will be something like the 14 plus. If anything, the 14 plus may reduce sales of 14 pro max.
It’s also lighter in weight due to the aluminum. I know a lot of people complain about that with the Pro Max. It doesn’t bother me, but everyone’s different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: klasma and brucemr
How do you expect it to start at $749 when the regular iPhone starts at $799 😂😂

I think it’s just different levels. It’s $200 cheaper than the Pro version just like the regular iPhone. People still buy it all the time even though for $200 extra, they could buy the Pro. They don’t need or want the Pro so why spend $200 for no reason.

I think people here are looking at it from a techy standpoint where why would you want less of a phone. I mean can we get the Ultra Pro Super Max for $1999
Regular iPhone 14 is priced too high. $699 starting price. It’s last years tech. Still a great phone, but both are overly priced. The 14 Plus will sell well because of screen size and battery. The 14 will be a dud. Too expensive, especially when you look at what you’re getting for $800.
 
I really don't understand how anybody can suggest a price cut. Have you been hiding somewhere underground for the past 12 months? Inflation is at least 20%. Is Apple expected to eat that inflation?

iPhone 13 should be selling for $875 today if Apple factored in inflation.

If everyone actually paid $200 more without thinking about it, then AirPods would not exist. Everyone would buy AirPods Pro. The iPad would not exist as everyone would buy iPad Air. Most people don't think that way. They look at what $200 offers and for a lot of people that third camera and pill isn't worth it.
 
I would bet a month’s salary that the plus will sell more. Most people want a larger phone with longer battery life.

The whole mini fiasco was because Apple miscalculated the market. There was a small but very vocal group of people that wanted a smaller iPhone. The problem they didn’t think about battery life. If the battery is almost half the size, it’s going to have a much shorter battery life even with a smaller screen. Perhaps the future is a mini size phone that folds out to a larger phone but currently the technology just isn’t here. Yes I know there are folding phones but they’re not ready for primetime.
How much of the poor sales do you reckon was because the mini was overpriced? I always felt like it was $100 too much (prior to the recent price drop).
 
Plus will sell better. The general public prefers the largest screen they can get for the dollar.

In the meantime, I'm waiting for the 14 series to be launched in my country to see how much the 13 mini will be discounted... 😅
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikext and klasma
How much of the poor sales do you reckon was because the mini was overpriced? I always felt like it was $100 too much (prior to the recent price drop).
Considering that more people are buying more expensive iphones, imo price is not the issue. It's simply the general market prefers larger phones if they are given the option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chidoro
The Plus will sell very well, but this is not it’s time to shine. The Pro phones are selling like hot cakes now because those are the phones that geeks like us order (or pre-order) to get at launch. We didn’t even look at the Plus.

The Plus will sell consistently well year round. We got my mom a new phone this past spring and she wanted the Pro Max, not because of any features, but because the screen was bigger and she could see it easier. The target market for the Plus won’t even know it exists until they walk into a carrier or Apple store.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Six0Four and ian87w
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.