Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

lexus

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Mar 26, 2006
1,569
0
Depends Greatly On The Weather
I know you can just disable PM's but I use them alot here on the board. My issue is that today I got a PM from someone who just registered advertising a product. I think there should be a minimum post count before you can send PM's.

Thanks for listening,
 
I think a 1 or 2 post minimum would work as the normal user is going to post a question before PM'ing someone first.
 
I don't think it would alienate newer members if say the minimum were pretty low, say 5 posts before you could PM. That said, if someone had a problem that was easier to deal with via PM's...I guess it would be frustrating to have to get through those first 5.
 
I could see a user who has lurked for sometime without registering/posting wanting to register in order to PM someone in response to a post they saw...this would obviously inhibit that.

lexus, I hope you reported that person to a mod. Have they been banned?
 
You can limit PMs to those on your Buddy List by checking the appropriate box under Edit Options in your User CP, too.
 
I could see a user who has lurked for sometime without registering/posting wanting to register in order to PM someone in response to a post they saw...this would obviously inhibit that.

lexus, I hope you reported that person to a mod. Have they been banned?

No, I did not have the time, who should I report them to?
 
I've read that spammers who used to join forums to post their spam (and be quickly banned) have yet another tactic: joining forums and sending junk PMs to as many people as possible. We haven't had many reports about this, at least so far, but we know it's a possibility. A minimum time between sending private messages prevents instant mass mailing of PMs, but it will certainly be an annoyance for all of us if unwanted junk PMs become a regular problem. Adding a minimum post count required for PMing could help a bit.

If you encounter this problem, or get any other type of unwanted PM, let us know. Tell us who sent you what by PM so we can take the appropriate action.

Rather that pick a particular moderator, it's best to use the Report Post system (that icon next to each post) to send us a message. It goes to the moderator "on duty" and works better than trying to tell or guess who's online at a given moment. You can't always tell.
 
Rather that pick a particular moderator, it's best to use the Report Post system (that icon next to each post) to send us a message. It goes to the moderator "on duty" and works better than trying to tell or guess who's online at a given moment. You can't always tell.

Yeah, using the "Report Post" is the best solution. That being said, if you want an easy way to know which Mods are currently online you can always just check out this link. :cool:
 
On a forum I'm an admin on, we had problems with new users signing up just to ask others via PM for (illegal) MP3s (it's a music related site). So, we found and installed a modification for vB that requires you to have at least 25 posts to send a PM to anyone besides an admin or mod (this still allows them to PM us should they have any legit questions, and if they PM us asking for MP3s, then they're dumber than we thought :D), but until 25 posts, no one besides us.

MR could implement something like this to allow newbies to still PM staff in case they have any questions or whatever.
 
Rather that pick a particular moderator, it's best to use the Report Post system (that icon next to each post) to send us a message. It goes to the moderator "on duty" and works better than trying to tell or guess who's online at a given moment. You can't always tell.

Unless I'm missing something, there is no Report Post system associated with PMs. That's why I suggested that lexus PM jsw. Am I wrong?
 
Unless I'm missing something, there is no Report Post system associated with PMs. That's why I suggested that lexus PM jsw. Am I wrong?
There is no report system associated with PMs, but you can report any forum post at all, just as a way to contact the moderator on duty about anything. As long as you explain the problem, we'll understand that it's not associated with that particular post. It's the same solution as when you want to report a general problem about a thread, not a particular post. You have to pick some post when you click the Report Post icon, but your report to us can explain what it's really about.

You can also use the Contact Us link at the bottom of every page to send us a message that's not about a particular post, but those aren't handled as promptly, so the Report Post system is the most practical method for most problems that members want to report.
 
min post requirements...

To be honest.. this is a suject near and dear to my heart.
I am , afterall, a reader and NOT a writer. I don't post unless something has really got my "panties in a knot" ( a pink and silky knot :p ). I can't tell you why i don't post... I just DON'T. I read.. I am here hours everyday... but I think in the time I have been a member I've only posted like maybe 4 times... And I lurked for years before i actually joined. I am sure there are a lot of people like me. Isn't it bad enough I'll NEVER have an Avatar on this forum until i'm in my 80's or 90's if at all? I mean I'm 27... and I MIGHT average about 1-4 posts a year... and with a 500 post requirement.. Well, you get my point. So basically IMO I think the fewer posting requirements the better. If you have to have them... please make them a very LOW number!

thanks for reading,

Ang
 
Don't sell yourself short...you've got 16 posts in the month since you signed up. At your current rate, you'll have an avatar in late 2009. :D
 
Permit PMs only from buddies; it works for me. Got sick and tired of hostile losers and strangers invading my head-space and cluttering up my inbox...

If your name's not down, you're not coming in.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.