Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ethandt72

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 10, 2016
14
2
We now have the redesign and unification of their OS across all devices, bringing in the “Liquid Glass” aesthetic and introducing a wide array of visual and UI changes across the board. For the most part I am really liking the changes and updates.

The one main thing that is bothering me are the controls for the new iTunes app on desktop, and the music app on iOS. The main area that shows you what track you are on, forward and backwards controls, volume, etc. The control center. It has been at the top on desktop since it’s inception I believe. Now they have it on the bottom, floating with the liquid glass effect. It doesn’t stand out. It’s awkward. And as far as I can tell I haven’t found a way to revert back to the “classic” look if you will. They include that for instance with their newer versions of the Mail app and now the Messages app.

This was a big miss for me as far as UI goes. I fully admit that I am older (53) so this could very well be me yelling at clouds and I accept that. Having to retrain my brain from going to the top of the window instead of the bottom to do the basic tasks of the app is obviously tripping me up as I am fighting years of habit.

At the very least they should allow users the ability to control the transparency of these elements to increase the visibility of these controls. Or it would be nice if they added an option to drag this module anywhere within the main window to reposition it where it works best for the user. If you are going to make it a floating control center then commit to it and let users conrtrol the position of it. Generally speaking there is less visual clutter at the top of the window than there is at the bottom.

Anyone uave any thoughts on this? Am I alone?
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Jumpthesnark
The one main thing that is bothering me are the controls for the new iTunes app on desktop, and the music app on iOS.
Didn't know there was a new iTunes app on Mac... or are you referring to the Music app on Mac?
 
What's annoying me with the Music app is that it opens as a small window that, even if I resize it, reverts to a small window the next time I open the app. Why won't Apple let me choose the window size?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ethandt72
What's annoying me with the Music app is that it opens as a small window that, even if I resize it, reverts to a small window the next time I open the app. Why won't Apple let me choose the window size?
I have that problem with almost every Apple app. I have a 34" 5K screen and get windows that open as in the screenshot below.

stupid-window-size.png
 
You're not alone. There is a lot of chatter about the Music app's new UI over on Apple's community forums (and apparently on Reddit too).

I have not updated to Tahoe mostly because of this. A friend updated and was alarmed that in "songs" view, he can no longer see the duration of a playlist he's created unless he scrolls to the bottom of the playlist. And if the playlist has any more than around 20 songs in it, you can't see the duration any more without scrolling (like on a laptop). Which you can in Sequoia and all previous versions. With all that wasted space at the top of the app screen, it's a pain that they put things like the controls and duration on the bottom.

It's a real usability issue for some of us and I hope they fix it, or give us a way to move/customize it, like OP said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ethandt72
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.