Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

SB1500

Suspended
Original poster
Dec 31, 2021
147
104
I am contemplating the MX Keys for Mac as an upgrade from a Logi K380 keyboard which I think is causing a bit of RSI for long term WFH use. A full size with the key panel will be perfect.

I had an MX Master mouse which has proved to be great ergonomically and is now 2 years old and not breaking so the natural next step is the MX keyboard.

The Apple keyboard would be nice in space grey but I have gotten used to the easy bluetooth switching between my company laptop and Mac and iPhone throughout the day so Logi has me!

Really, I am asking are there any obvious reasons NOT to buy this from existing owners?
 
I've been using the MX Keys for Mac for about two years now, and find it to be an excellent keyboard. The keys feel good to type on, and the software has been great. The battery life is excellent, and the fact that it's charged via USB-C makes it easy to add into my setup. Unlike most 3rd-party accessories that use Bluetooth with Apple computers, it seems to not have any issues keeping a constant connection with no glitches. The auto-sense and adjustable backlighting is a nice touch as well.

If I have one complaint it is that the MX Keys is a heavy keyboard—I mean really heavy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUQRU
The only issue I have read about here on the forums is the KB won't work to let you login if you have FileVault turned on. As I understand it, the FileVault login screen is not running the drivers required , so the KB won't work. Once you get logged in, it works fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roadster Lewis
I used one for 2 weeks, hated it and sent it back to Amazon. Squeeshy, mushy, long travel keys. The latest Magic Keyboard is miles better imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlphaCentauri
The only issue I have read about here on the forums is the KB won't work to let you login if you have FileVault turned on. As I understand it, the FileVault login screen is not running the drivers required , so the KB won't work. Once you get logged in, it works fine.
Yes, unfortunately this is true. You need wired or apple magic keyboard to login if FileVault is turned on, after that works perfectly fine. I am using this Logitech MX keys with MacBook 16 2019 currently. Unfortunately connecting via dongle and type-c cable doesn’t help as well. So using MacBook keyboard to login and after that enjoying mx keys.

despite this I love an experience I have with MX keys, especially ability easily switching between my MacBook and iPad Pro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Weaselboy
My K380 bluetooth keyboard used to be like this, wouldn't work until the login screen on my old Intel Macs. but my M1, they work beautifully.

So far, the MX Keys is the number one choice. Though Logitech keep emailing me with these special weird looking ergo keyboards and I'm wondering if they're actually any better comfort wise?
 
What is the "loudness" of the MX Keys compared to Magic Keyboard 2?
Spending the whole day in telcos, I am looking for the quietest keyboard I can get (without numpad)... I have seen the reviews on Rtings where they rate Apple keyboard as ultra-quiet, but I am not sure..
 
Is it still an issue, that the MX Keys are not connected on initial startup? So that I cannot enter my account password at login?
 
I have the Black MX Keys and I could never go back to the Apple Magic Keyboard. I loathe the typing experience on that Keyboard after using the full size MX Keys. Having the keys backlit is just icing on the cake, and the battery lasts forever. I think the key travel is perfect, but I find the Magic Keyboards travel way to shallow and its uncomfortable for me to type on.
 
I bought the MX keys keyboard 2 weeks ago and love it. I work on both windows and macs so the ability to switch back and forth is imperative.

It took a minute or two to get used to - but it definitely has increased my productivity, and is SUPER comfortable to type on. Great keyboard traction, and connects to devices quickly and easily.

Couldn’t be happier with my purchase ☺️
 
Is it still an issue, that the MX Keys are not connected on initial startup? So that I cannot enter my account password at login?

Not an issue if the connection is through the Unifying Receiver, making it act like an USB keyboard.

But with the BT connection, if those drivers aren't loaded prior to the FV prompt, the keyboard cannot connect.

Apple rectified that for their own wireless keyboards, but not third party keyboards. However, there are some reports that more recent versions of Monterey do allow such keyboards to connect, and not require disabling FV like Logitech suggests, or having a second keyboard on hand to log in, if one prefers BT as the connection method.

It's not clear what effected the change, software or never hardware.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUQRU
If you have the Mac version they no longer include the Unifying Receiver. So if you buy the Mac version do yourself a favor and spend $10 on the receiver. Rock solid connection. The receiver is a tiny USB plug that I keep plugged into my OWC dock USB 2 port so it is not taking any space away from the USB 3 or C ports.

The receiver supports multiple devices, so my MX Master 3 is also connected to it.
 
Not an issue if the connection is through the Unifying Receiver, making it act like an USB keyboard.

But with the BT connection, if those drivers aren't loaded prior to the FV prompt, the keyboard cannot connect.

Apple rectified that for their own wireless keyboards, but not third party keyboards. However, there are some reports that more recent versions of Monterey do allow such keyboards to connect, and not require disabling FV like Logitech suggests, or having a second keyboard on hand to log in, if one prefers BT as the connection method.

It's not clear what effected the change, software or never hardware.
I connect the MX Keys via Bluetooth and don't have an issue entering my password at startup. It's a well built keyboard with slightly better feeling keys than the Magic Keyboard.
 
Not an issue if the connection is through the Unifying Receiver, making it act like an USB keyboard.

But with the BT connection, if those drivers aren't loaded prior to the FV prompt, the keyboard cannot connect.

Apple rectified that for their own wireless keyboards, but not third party keyboards. However, there are some reports that more recent versions of Monterey do allow such keyboards to connect, and not require disabling FV like Logitech suggests, or having a second keyboard on hand to log in, if one prefers BT as the connection method.

It's not clear what effected the change, software or never hardware.
I've never had that problem with any version of macOS, MX Keys or other brand keyboards
 
If you have the Mac version they no longer include the Unifying Receiver. So if you buy the Mac version do yourself a favor and spend $10 on the receiver. Rock solid connection. The receiver is a tiny USB plug that I keep plugged into my OWC dock USB 2 port so it is not taking any space away from the USB 3 or C ports.

The receiver supports multiple devices, so my MX Master 3 is also connected to it.

The Mini for Mac version has never been bundled with the USB receiver. The full-sized Mac model has included the receiver in the box, and if that's no longer the case, it is a more recent development. Logitech's site still claims it does, at least for the U.S. model 920-009552.

But it is a good point to note, since Logitech's product managers do like to play such omission games, which sometimes gives one version a better value proposition, with only minor, and sometimes even no other differences in the hardware.

I connect the MX Keys via Bluetooth and don't have an issue entering my password at startup. It's a well built keyboard with slightly better feeling keys than the Magic Keyboard.

Due to the way Mac OS has loaded components during boot, BT compatibility has been an issue for third party peripherals when FileVault is enabled. It has been discussed time and again, here, here, and here, for example, with many more to be found.

The issue has been so common in fact, that Logitech felt the need to include this disclaimer on the MXK product page as a "feature," as well as in the FAQs, and on the product packaging itself.

ATTENTION: FILEVAULT​


FileVault is an encryption system available on some Mac computers. When enabled, it might prevent Bluetooth® devices from connecting with your computer if you have not yet logged in. If you have FileVault enabled, we recommend using the provided USB receiver to use your keyboard.

Bluetooth mouse or keyboard not recognized after reboot on macOS (Intel-based Mac) - FileVault


If your Bluetooth mouse or keyboard does not reconnect after a reboot at the login screen and only reconnects after the login, this might be related to FileVault encryption.
When FileVault is enabled, Bluetooth mice and keyboards will only re-connect after login.
Potential solutions:
  • If your Logitech device came with a USB receiver, using it will solve the issue.
  • Use your MacBook keyboard and trackpad to login.
  • Use a USB keyboard or mouse to login.
Note: This issue is fixed from macOS 12.3 or later on M1. Users with an older version might still experience it.

The fact that you, or others, say that you have not experienced any issues, without providing any context, does not preclude the possibility that it does occur for others, with enough frequency to warrant the steps that Logitech has taken to notify users and make its recommendations. It is even more acute for those who purchase a model that does not include the USB receiver in the box, leaving the user with only one of the recommended options, to disable FileVault, unless they make a separate purchase.

While, in hindsight, the decision to abbreviate FileVault to FV did hamper clarity, none of what was said in the earlier post was false, and Logitech has validated the speculation that more recent versions of Mac OS do work differently and are able to avoid the issue.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.