iPod Nano or shuffle?

[carve]

I do not know which one to get, either the 2GB silver nano or the 1GB shuffle. I am almost leaning on the nano side because it has a screen, and there is also something to hold on to. But then the shuffle is tiniest mp3 player i've ever seen. But please help me decide because I have enough for the nano. Thanks, macluver101

 

[WildCowboy]

How important is a screen to you? I have a first-generation 1 GB shuffle and love it. But I'm usually near my computer when I'm using it, with quick access to the playlist in case an unknown song comes on.

At some point I'll probably pick up a nano, but the screen just isn't that important to me, so I'm ticking along fine with my shuffle.

 

[Rojo]

I do not know which one to get, either the 2GB silver nano or the 1GB shuffle. I am almost leaning on the nano side because it has a screen, and there is also something to hold on to. But then the shuffle is tiniest mp3 player i've ever seen. But please help me decide because I have enough for the nano. Thanks, macluver101

What's more important to you?
Larger storage capacity or super-compactness?

 

[puckhead193]

get the nano... i just got a 2GB one and love it!