Ok, lets get all of the information in one place here
Correct me if I am wrong about something
You have an external HDD (how is it connected? FW? USB?)
USB
You can see it in Disk Utility (in the left column?
YES
You cannot erase it with Disk Utility
NOPE
Did you select the actual drive or a partition under the drive?
ACTUAL (course now the partition under is MIA for some reason)
Did you select Mac OS Extended (Journaled)?
YES
Have you tried to Repair Disk from Disk Utility?
YES - But it doesn't show in there right now but the 2 times it showed with an actual non-greyed button - I ran Repair Disk and it came up with Invalid Index Key (I think that's what it said). Fail.
Any other relevant information you can share?
ODDLY - twice in the last 2 days I got a message saying "external is being made available to you for a limited time" Something like that. I quickly tried to grab some vids off it and copy it back but my POS iMac froze so I had to reboot and now I lost the mount again.
Also - Tried TechTool Pro and Diskwarrior.
What type of drive? Acomdata that has a WD 500 in it. Forgot the name.
What is the original format? I thought it said HFS? I'm not sure. I can't see it in Disk Utility right now either. The light on it is rapidly flashing all kinds of crazy colors. No clue what it's doing.
Apple owes me a new iMac and I'm holding off till Fall in case new ones come up but boy is this thing on the edge of total death.
External won't show up on my Air either.
I think the "Invalid Index Key" error in Disk Utility might mean a very bad thing. Just frustrating cuz I know the files are all in there.