Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

countryhick

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 4, 2024
11
12
Brisbane, Australia
So firstly I've got to admit I might have a little bit of an addiction to buying every cheap 12,2 iMac on FB MP.... 🤣
and Secondly.... NO!!! My fans aren't spinning at MAX after replacing the HDD or leaving a temp sensor unplugged 😝

The screenshots below pretty much outline all the machine specifics..
**All of them have had a solder bridge between pin 6 and 7 on the SATA power pins on the logic board. To stop the HDD fan running at MAX once the factory HDD has been replaced with an SSD. As outlined HERE.**

What I started to notice with so many 12,2's is the HDD fan would spin at a baseline of 2500rpm on some... and 1100rpm on others... 🤔
After searching for a correlation between the the machines with the same behavior, the only thing I could see is the SMC Versions differed (refer photos).

So the machines that have
SMC: 1.72f5 (HDD idle fan speed = 2500rpm) Noticeable fan noise
SMC: 1.72f1 (HDD idle fan speed = 1100rpm) Minimal fan noise

All these machines usually have AMD WX3200 GPU's installed in them running Sequoia via OCLP... But because OCLP spoofs the "System Firmware" and "SMC Version" numbers... I reverted the GPU back to a HD6770M and a HDD I had laying around with HS installed on it so I could capture the screenshots..
>>The fans behave Identical as above when the WX3200's and OCLP are in play....<<

Has anyone else noticed this?
How does SMC Ver: 1.17f2 Behave??
Is it possible to RollBack/Flash older SMC versions?

***Yes I could just use 'Macs Fan Control' or similar... But I would prefer not to if possible***

I can see how having that higher idle HDD fan speed would make sense trying to keep HDD plater drives running cooler... But is it really needed for SSD's??? 🤷‍♂️



BAD_iMac6.png
BAD_iMac10.png
GOOD_iMac5.png
GOOD_iMac7.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrZupp
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.