Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Optibay HDD unsafe?
- Thread starter 2Turbo
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
i'm curious about this too as i just updated to a ssd and are using the optibay for the regular HD. where did you read this?
Modern harddrives will automatically park the heads by using the power generating from the still spinning platters in the event of a power loss.
I would imagine the greater risk is that the drive is hard mounted in the optibay, vs rubber dampers in the normal spot.
I would imagine the greater risk is that the drive is hard mounted in the optibay, vs rubber dampers in the normal spot.
I wonder how noticeable the real world difference is between having an SSD in a SATA 2 slot instead of one that supports SATA 3. It's good to note that currently there aren't nearly as many SATA 3 SSDs as there are SATA 2 SSDs
Or you could always put an SSD in both places and make a raid.
However a raid confined to sata 2 :\
We'll be seeing more tests of SATA 3 drives as they come to market. I'm curious to see the difference too.
Either there is no solid info out there or my googlefu is in the dumps today...
So - I intend on installing a 750 Gb drive in my optibay. I am going for the 7200 Seagate Drive with their SMS like system
My current system: 2011 15" with a 256Gb SSD preinstalled.
Question:
1. Is there a definitive answer as to whether or not the SMS will work with a drive in that bay? (Apple's SMS - I understand the Seagate has it's own built in)
(Qualifier: As I understand it, SMS is tied to the SATA bus. The SATA bus directly reports to the CPU. With that, would it not matter where the hard drive is installed as long as the OS recognizes the drive is of the spinning platter type?) Sorry if I am not clear.
2. Vibration control. Most rubber grommet mounting styles are that - rubber grommets. For those of you that have stock drives, do those drives have mounting grommets?
My follow on question would be - could not one manufacture rubber grommets to provide a similar vibration absorption system if said system is installed with the stock drive? If no grommets are installed on the stock system then the question is moot.
Thanks.
So - I intend on installing a 750 Gb drive in my optibay. I am going for the 7200 Seagate Drive with their SMS like system
My current system: 2011 15" with a 256Gb SSD preinstalled.
Question:
1. Is there a definitive answer as to whether or not the SMS will work with a drive in that bay? (Apple's SMS - I understand the Seagate has it's own built in)
(Qualifier: As I understand it, SMS is tied to the SATA bus. The SATA bus directly reports to the CPU. With that, would it not matter where the hard drive is installed as long as the OS recognizes the drive is of the spinning platter type?) Sorry if I am not clear.
2. Vibration control. Most rubber grommet mounting styles are that - rubber grommets. For those of you that have stock drives, do those drives have mounting grommets?
My follow on question would be - could not one manufacture rubber grommets to provide a similar vibration absorption system if said system is installed with the stock drive? If no grommets are installed on the stock system then the question is moot.
Thanks.
1. The main reason people put HDDs in the HD bay on MBPs is that the MBP itself has an SMS. If your Seagate drive already has an SMS built in, you'd be better off putting your HDD in the optibay, since the 2 SMS's will conflict with each other and cause problems. The Seagate's SMS will work fine in the Optibay.
2. I'm not sure that most 7200 RPM laptop drives really vibrate all that much. The vibration is likely going to be negligible, and most optibays will simply cover up the sound/vibration anyway.