Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

shadowfax0

macrumors 6502
Original poster
May 2, 2002
408
0
I want to get my brother an iPod for Xmas; however, he has a PC. I know there are PC iPods, but what do I have to do to get one? Do I just go up to the guy in the Apple store and say "Yeah, I need a PC iPod?" or will any iPod do; is there a difference between the two? Can anyone tell me if he will need Xplay or anyhting like that? Thanks!
 
Originally posted by Gus


Umm, no it won't. If you buy the Mac version, because it is formatted in HFS extended, the PC will not see it. Also, the PC software needed to import your music will not be included. Yes, you can take a PC iPod and make it Mac, but it won't work the other way around.

Regards,
Gus

Umm, dude, I think you misread edvniow's post.


Lethal
 
Isn't that what I said?

Click on that link and scroll down to MacBandit's post. He took a PC iPod and plugged it into his Mac and it worked just like a Mac iPod, no formatting, no extra software, no anything. The Mac version won't work like that since it's formatted in HFS and Windows can't read that format while Macs can read both HFS and FAT32 which the PC iPod is formatted in.
The PC version comes with the Musicmatch software which is needed I believe so if you want an iPod which will work on both platforms, get the PC one.
 
Well call me an idiot. I humbly apologize. I wasn't trying to be mean, I just didn't understand what your message was. The title of that post made it sound like you were agreeing with the title of the post rather than the contents of it. Once again, my bad. I just wanted to make sure that the original poster didn't misread and buy the Mac version which wouldn't work with his brother's PC. Just wanted to cover the bases.

Sorry about the confusion on my part!

Regards,
Gus
 
Why doesn't Apple just make one version? If the PC version works fine on the Mac, its in Apple's interests to have less options to build for. I dont understand.
 
It's because us Apple people don't want any connection to the PC world! (I say this as I'm on an HP at school...)
 
I guess its always been the same. Even going back to using floppy disc (I used PC formatted disks so I could use them on my Mac + also on PC's.). Oh well.
 
Originally posted by Falleron
Why doesn't Apple just make one version? If the PC version works fine on the Mac, its in Apple's interests to have less options to build for. I dont understand.

The standard connections between the platforms are different. :p
 
Originally posted by edvniow


Not really.

Most computers have 6-pin FW (the kind you see on Macs) and few have 4-pin (Sony's iLink) so FW is the same on Mac or PC.

I think that was a joke - same different standards - teehee, get IT?:p
 
I went to Target in Redwood City, CA to get some Advanced Gameboy games for my newphews and they didn't have any iPod's on display. When I asked the clerk he knew nothing. But could have asked him about anything and he'd know nothing.
 
Originally posted by pgwalsh
I went to Target in Redwood City, CA to get some Advanced Gameboy games for my newphews and they didn't have any iPod's on display. When I asked the clerk he knew nothing. But could have asked him about anything and he'd know nothing.

I haven't seen any at my local target in Waterloo, Iowa either. I however have seen them at Best Buys.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.