Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Pitaka protection vs Apple cases?

C

CaramelSky

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 11, 2022
108
86
Hey guys

I'm super tempted by this Pitaka MagEZ case for my 15 Pro, but I'm worried about the protection it offers.
www.ipitaka.com

Sunset Moonrise Phone Cases | PITAKA

Make your phone stand out with PITAKA Sunset Moonrise cases. These cases utilize premium aramid fiber to capture the enchanting moments of sunset and moonrise, protecting your device while adding unique aesthetics.
www.ipitaka.com www.ipitaka.com

I've always used Apple Silicone cases and never had an issue with those, the drops I've had seem to be well tolerated by the Apple Silicone cases.

I'm just wondering if they offer a similar amount of protection, or if the Apple case tends to handle drops better?

If they're similar I'll probably pull the trigger on the Pitaka.

Thanks!
 
CaramelSky said:
Hey guys

I'm super tempted by this Pitaka MagEZ case for my 15 Pro, but I'm worried about the protection it offers.
www.ipitaka.com

Sunset Moonrise Phone Cases | PITAKA

Make your phone stand out with PITAKA Sunset Moonrise cases. These cases utilize premium aramid fiber to capture the enchanting moments of sunset and moonrise, protecting your device while adding unique aesthetics.
www.ipitaka.com www.ipitaka.com

I've always used Apple Silicone cases and never had an issue with those, the drops I've had seem to be well tolerated by the Apple Silicone cases.

I'm just wondering if they offer a similar amount of protection, or if the Apple case tends to handle drops better?

If they're similar I'll probably pull the trigger on the Pitaka.

Thanks!
Click to expand...
I love my Pitaka cases! With that being said, I definitely think that the silicone would offer more protection in any type of drop. The silicone are thicker and well.....made of silicone which is rubber-like in texture. Also, the sides don't really come up as far as the screen on my 16PM with screen protector on. if it falls on the screen, it will hit the screen protector before it would hit the sides coming up on the pitaka case. I use pitaka because I am very careful with my devices and also have applecare. If you want me to I can take side by side photos of the pitaka and silicone to give you an idea of what I am talking about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ascNYC
Yandawg said:
I love my Pitaka cases! With that being said, I definitely think that the silicone would offer more protection in any type of drop. The silicone are thicker and well.....made of silicone which is rubber-like in texture. Also, the sides don't really come up as far as the screen on my 16PM with screen protector on. if it falls on the screen, it will hit the screen protector before it would hit the sides coming up on the pitaka case. I use pitaka because I am very careful with my devices and also have applecare. If you want me to I can take side by side photos of the pitaka and silicone to give you an idea of what I am talking about.
Click to expand...
Would love a picture, that would be so amazing... thank you so much!

I do have applecare and i'm generally quite careful, it's just the once in a blue moon drop that happens on a rough surface. Usually if its dropped itll be from a metre onto carpet or something
 
These should show you what I am talking about. On a side note, I just sent my silicone case back and will just rock the pitaka. After using the camera control between the two, the pitaka works better for me. Since there is a cutout in the pitaka, I can find the camera control quicker with my index finger. The silicone doesn’t have a huge delineation
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0090.jpeg
    IMG_0090.jpeg
    439.8 KB · Views: 347
  • IMG_0091.jpeg
    IMG_0091.jpeg
    381.3 KB · Views: 344
  • IMG_0089.jpeg
    IMG_0089.jpeg
    430.5 KB · Views: 342
  • IMG_0088.jpeg
    IMG_0088.jpeg
    393.3 KB · Views: 328
  • IMG_0086.jpeg
    IMG_0086.jpeg
    398.6 KB · Views: 338
  • Like
Reactions: rmadsen3 and JiggyJaggy
@Yandawg are you getting any issues with the touch screen not responding because your hand touches the edge of the screen with the Pitaka? I know theres an iOS 18 bug that causes this and when I tried to use the pitaka, it would trigger the bug. I got the black case so its a bit thinner so I am curious if the added thickness of the colored version has a better lip
 
masterxchief said:
@Yandawg are you getting any issues with the touch screen not responding because your hand touches the edge of the screen with the Pitaka? I know theres an iOS 18 bug that causes this and when I tried to use the pitaka, it would trigger the bug. I got the black case so its a bit thinner so I am curious if the added thickness of the colored version has a better lip
Click to expand...
I haven’t encountered this issue so far.
 
CaramelSky said:
Hey guys

I'm super tempted by this Pitaka MagEZ case for my 15 Pro, but I'm worried about the protection it offers.
www.ipitaka.com

Sunset Moonrise Phone Cases | PITAKA

Make your phone stand out with PITAKA Sunset Moonrise cases. These cases utilize premium aramid fiber to capture the enchanting moments of sunset and moonrise, protecting your device while adding unique aesthetics.
www.ipitaka.com www.ipitaka.com

I've always used Apple Silicone cases and never had an issue with those, the drops I've had seem to be well tolerated by the Apple Silicone cases.

I'm just wondering if they offer a similar amount of protection, or if the Apple case tends to handle drops better?

If they're similar I'll probably pull the trigger on the Pitaka.

Thanks!
Click to expand...
IMG_0574.jpeg


No issues here with my Pitaka case on my 16 PM. Offers good grip!
 
I had the exact same Pitaka case on my 15PM, and that's the only case I ever dropped my phone in since iPhone 4 (and dropped twice!). The edge of the case roughed up, screen protector shattered, but the phone was ok. I like the texture but find it slippery, which is (what I think) why I dropped my phone. Could just be coincidence though.
 
CaramelSky said:
Hey guys

I'm super tempted by this Pitaka MagEZ case for my 15 Pro, but I'm worried about the protection it offers.
www.ipitaka.com

Sunset Moonrise Phone Cases | PITAKA

Make your phone stand out with PITAKA Sunset Moonrise cases. These cases utilize premium aramid fiber to capture the enchanting moments of sunset and moonrise, protecting your device while adding unique aesthetics.
www.ipitaka.com www.ipitaka.com

I've always used Apple Silicone cases and never had an issue with those, the drops I've had seem to be well tolerated by the Apple Silicone cases.

I'm just wondering if they offer a similar amount of protection, or if the Apple case tends to handle drops better?

If they're similar I'll probably pull the trigger on the Pitaka.

Thanks!
Click to expand...

get the "military grade" one instead

www.ipitaka.com

Sunset Moonrise Phone Cases | PITAKA

Make your phone stand out with PITAKA Sunset Moonrise cases. These cases utilize premium aramid fiber to capture the enchanting moments of sunset and moonrise, protecting your device while adding unique aesthetics.
www.ipitaka.com www.ipitaka.com
 
  • Like
Reactions: screamace
Yandawg said:
These should show you what I am talking about. On a side note, I just sent my silicone case back and will just rock the pitaka. After using the camera control between the two, the pitaka works better for me. Since there is a cutout in the pitaka, I can find the camera control quicker with my index finger. The silicone doesn’t have a huge delineation
Click to expand...
How is the grip on Pitaka vs. Apple Silicon case? Is it comparable? Are Pitaka cases slippery ? Thanks
 
mlody said:
How is the grip on Pitaka vs. Apple Silicon case? Is it comparable? Are Pitaka cases slippery ? Thanks
Click to expand...
They are different. If I had to pick one, I think the pitaka has more grip. The silicone is rubbery feeling and has decent grip. The pitaka is textered due to the woven materials. It is not highly textured, but you can feel it if you rub your hand across it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mlody
Yandawg said:
They are different. If I had to pick one, I think the pitaka has more grip. The silicone is rubbery feeling and has decent grip. The pitaka is textered due to the woven materials. It is not highly textured, but you can feel it if you rub your hand across it.
Click to expand...
I appreciate the insight. Which case picks up more lint when in a pocket? That is one of the main reasons I hate the silicon cases and I am very upset that Apple stopped selling leather cases. What used to be a no brainer decision, now I am loosing my mind trying to get a nice case for my 16 Pro.
 
Yeah, I loved the leather cases. As far as lint, I can’t really say. I haven’t put the silicone one on yet. I am pretty content with the pitaka. About the only time I put the silicone case on is when I am on my jet ski and it is bouncing around inside, or if I know I am gonna be getting really drunk like going on a cruise or something like that…lmao
 
  • Like
Reactions: mlody
that is a nice case, all you need to have is a tempered glass screen protector.
if you have that combo, you will be 100% fine
 
I've dropped phones in the old style (no bottom or top coverage). The case was messed up and there was a single "dent" in the metal (steel) at the top of the phone. I suspect now, a normal drop will just damage the case unless you happen to hit it near the uncovered buttons.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back