Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Mord

macrumors G4
Original poster
Aug 24, 2003
10,091
23
UK
www.powerlogix.com


a few cuts in price and a new 1.1GHz g3 upgrade (would like to see a comparison with the sonnet 1GHz g4 (66MHz bus for B&W's))i would recommend the g3 for blue&Whites and the sonnet for beige's
 
I think in some functions the G3 @ 100 bus would cream the G4 at 66. But you cannot compete with Altivec. There is a lot of the core OS that utilizes Altivec. That performance hit for the 66 bus on a B&W is made up for with the G4.
Take ripping a CD. The G4 just wins hands down. I have a 400 G$ powerbook and a 500 G3 powerbook. The G4 beats it by 50% on the same song.

But on non-altivec stuff, the G3 will often be gfaster for me.
Hector said:
www.powerlogix.com


a few cuts in price and a new 1.1GHz g3 upgrade (would like to see a comparison with the sonnet 1GHz g4 (66MHz bus for B&W's))i would recommend the g3 for blue&Whites and the sonnet for beige's
 
but the bus bottle necks it so very very much i remember reading a review of the sonnet from a guy who upgraded from a 500MHz g4 and he said it felt more like a downgrade in some areas.


I have a Blue&White G3 and i am going to get an XLR8 daystar 600MHz g4 for it thats certifyed at 650MHz and only costs $200
 
My blue and white G3 often outworks my dual G4 on one processor since I got my PowerLogix G3/800 upgrade. Both run at 800 MHz but only those things which are AltiVec-enhanced really shine on the dual G4. I'd like to see if the 1.1 GHz G3 is still better but it's a lot of money for the moment.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.