Rebel Scholar v Incase Slider

[AVFC]

Which one is best?

 

[hsk]

Very similar products - if you search on YouTube you will find some reviews. The Scholar seems to be a tad thicker than the Slider.

 

[AGIPSY]

Very similar products - if you search on YouTube you will find some reviews. The Scholar seems to be a tad thicker than the Slider.

really? I think I heard the opposite.....

 

[hsk]

Here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eksr55WrCg4

He stacks them together about 1/2 through the review. Rebel looks thicker to me - and to him.

 

[V4705]

there are few "versions" of the scholars,
some with silicone rails, some without.
i saw video review with one case that fits tight enough and the other one was too loose.

i think, if you get a tight one with silicone rails, it will be good as the incase.