Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

christiannielsen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Apr 9, 2023
3
0
I am considering buying an apple watch cellular and have a few questions.

It it true, that the watch is not able to receive any ordinary texts/sms that are not an iMessage, if my iphone is turned off?
 
I have another question as well. Does the telephone carrier on my iPhone have to be the same as on a apple watch eSim?
 
For SMS, your paired iPhone must be able to receive the SMS and must be connected to the Internet. Your Watch must also have an Internet connection, but it doesn’t need a cellular connection. However, so long as those conditions are met, the Watch and the iPhone can be on opposite sides of the planet. (Same for sending as receiving.)

As best I know, the only Watch plans you can get are add-ons to existing iPhone plans. Whether this is a technical limitation or a marketing one, I’ve no clue.

It’s worth noting that SMS is one of the few, and perhaps the most annoying, features that requires an actually-on iPhone. Next in line would be some 2FA systems. There are also a few third-party apps that just use the Watch as a front-end to the iPhone and require the Watch to be connected directly to the iPhone via Bluetooth or WiFi; for example, the ReSound hearing aid app works that way.

Other than those small caveats, you can use a cellular Apple Watch entirely independently of its paired iPhone, even when the iPhone is dead as a doornail. You can make and receive phone calls, access voicemail, send and receive iMessages, email, ApplePay … the works.

I’m not shy about leaving home without the iPhone — and, when I do have it with me, it’s often buried in a backpack and not in my pocket; I’m often quite happy using my Ultra for most smartphone-type things. And it was an absolute godsend for a few days when my iPhone was, indeed, dead as a doornail. Of course, I’ll break out the iPhone for its camera, or to read something, or for DuoLingo, or the like. Basically, the iPhone is, for me, a mini tablet with a great camera, and the Watch is my smartphone.

b&
 
I am considering buying an apple watch cellular and have a few questions.

It it true, that the watch is not able to receive any ordinary texts/sms that are not an iMessage, if my iphone is turned off?
Apple support page says the following…
  • To receive SMS, MMS, or push notifications from third-party apps on your Apple Watch with cellular, your paired iPhone must be powered on and connected to Wi-Fi or cellular.
 
For SMS, your paired iPhone must be able to receive the SMS and must be connected to the Internet. Your Watch must also have an Internet connection, but it doesn’t need a cellular connection. However, so long as those conditions are met, the Watch and the iPhone can be on opposite sides of the planet. (Same for sending as receiving.)

As best I know, the only Watch plans you can get are add-ons to existing iPhone plans. Whether this is a technical limitation or a marketing one, I’ve no clue.

It’s worth noting that SMS is one of the few, and perhaps the most annoying, features that requires an actually-on iPhone. Next in line would be some 2FA systems. There are also a few third-party apps that just use the Watch as a front-end to the iPhone and require the Watch to be connected directly to the iPhone via Bluetooth or WiFi; for example, the ReSound hearing aid app works that way.

Other than those small caveats, you can use a cellular Apple Watch entirely independently of its paired iPhone, even when the iPhone is dead as a doornail. You can make and receive phone calls, access voicemail, send and receive iMessages, email, ApplePay … the works.

I’m not shy about leaving home without the iPhone — and, when I do have it with me, it’s often buried in a backpack and not in my pocket; I’m often quite happy using my Ultra for most smartphone-type things. And it was an absolute godsend for a few days when my iPhone was, indeed, dead as a doornail. Of course, I’ll break out the iPhone for its camera, or to read something, or for DuoLingo, or the like. Basically, the iPhone is, for me, a mini tablet with a great camera, and the Watch is my smartphone.

b&
Can you get new voicemails notifications on watch if your iPhone is completely turned off? For some people if we get a new call on watch and iPhone is turned off when the call goes to voicemail and someone leaves a msg the watch does not receive a VM notification nor is the VM available in the watch’s phone app until the iPhone gets turned back on. Very odd.
 
Last edited:
Apple support page says the following…
  • To receive SMS, MMS, or push notifications from third-party apps on your Apple Watch with cellular, your paired iPhone must be powered on and connected to Wi-Fi or cellular.

And by third-party apps means for example a sms/text message from a samsung phone?

I do not understand why a simple text message can't be delivered directly to the watch when a simple call can.
 
I do not understand why a simple text message can't be delivered directly to the watch when a simple call can.

Nobody else understands, either. Nor do any of us like it. But that’s the way it is.

Will Apple ever fix this? One would have expected them to a looooong time ago, yet they haven’t. So I’m not holding my breath.

The good news is that, in practice, it’s almost never a problem. If you’ve got an Apple Watch, you’ve got an iPhone; and, if you have an iPhone, either you’re keeping it near you like most people, or you know about this limitation and you make sure that, when you leave the iPhone behind, you leave it plugged in and connected so it can act as the relay. The end result seems as if the Watch was directly handling the SMS messages, up until the point that your iPhone shuts down or otherwise becomes isolated from the cellular network or the Internet.

b&
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.