That's strange. I'm not doubting your experience, but when I called the Apple Store to ask the same question the day before yesterday, the person I talked to said that the rebate DID apply to refurb Macs. And indeed, on the rebate form itself, it doesn't say anything about the Mac having to be brand-spanking-new or not a refurb or anything like that. Certainly if they only meant new, they would have said "refurbs are not eligible" or something like that, just as easily as they list the brands of printers that are part of the deal.