Safari icon needs this I think...

[Appledict]

I've made this on PS CS6 in 5 minutes give or take. It looks much better without white border. What are you thinking about new icon? Better? Worse?

How it looks on home screen...

 

[Apple_Robert]

Why not make the post in one of the numerous iOS 7 icon threads that are still active?

 

[ZacNicholson]

Why not make the post in one of the numerous iOS 7 icon threads that are still active?

If he did that then his amazing mockup would be over looked

 

[Tmelon]

I think the icon needs a little more than a blue border.

 

[Northernist]

Looks too much like the clock, IMO..

And the Safari icon doesn't "need" anything.

 

[falconeight]

Wow! that looks exactly the same.

 

[joejoejoe]

Looks too much like the clock, IMO..

And the Safari icon doesn't "need" anything.

it "needs" a redesign. it's ugly.

 

[Armen]

The blue contrasts with the needle better than white does.

 

[J.C]

Looks nice.

 

[xkmxkmxlmx]

Looks better. Either way, they should just redesign the Safari icon in general. Only because they have an actual compass app that comes with iOS.

 

[heyyoudvd]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:

(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

 

[naasrd]

No, too much white.

 

[aDRock1154]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

For the win.

 

[vcao]

I've made this on PS CS6 in 5 minutes give or take. It looks much better without white border. What are you thinking about new icon? Better? Worse?

Image

How it looks on home screen...

Image

Would look better as this bookmark icon. Or no circle at all

 

[AlphaDeuce]

Too much white space in the middle. But I would take that mock up over the current icon.

 

[Drunken Master]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

Too retrograde.

 

[notrack]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

Much better, I'd be absolutely fine with that.

 

[Pompiliu]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

It's much better than the stock one.

 

[Megakazbek]

Old Safari icon was map with compass over it, at least suggesting something to do with safari. Now icon is just compass, and no matter how nice it's rendered, it's a compass icon, not Safari icon, and it's weird to see it alongside the compass app. I think first thing that should be done with this icon is a better metaphor, not better rendering.

 

[robertpatryk]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

Sure, but it can't be done this way because of the circle. It has to follow the "icon design pattern".

 

[notrack]

Sure, but it can't be done this way because of the circle. It has to follow the "icon design pattern".

Imho that pattern is just random lines not following any standards like the rule of thirds ore the golden cut. At least i haven't noticed it.

 

[Gogurt48]

Old Safari icon was map with compass over it, at least suggesting something to do with safari. Now icon is just compass, and no matter how nice it's rendered, it's a compass icon, not Safari icon, and it's weird to see it alongside the compass app. I think first thing that should be done with this icon is a better metaphor, not better rendering.

Agreed. How about a compass needle over an outline of Africa? Or, instead of an outline, maybe the icon could be blue, with a depiction of Africa in the middle that's a slightly lighter shade of blue, so you can barely see it. That might suggest a safari.

 

[rk25123]

I like these better, designed by Louie Mantia.

 

[myrtlebee]

Of all the Safari redesigns I've seen so far, this one's my favourite:


Image


(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

Too intricate for the remaining icons. Ditch the N, S, E, W and edge triangular indents and maybe it's a go

This is even better:

I like these better, designed by Louie Mantia.

 

[204353]

(Of course, it's not my work. I'm not sure who created it, but whoever did, did a nice job.)

Judging from the watermark in the bottom-right, I'd say it's by Patrick Mauldin. And yeah, it's a nice icon.