Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Drewps5co0tt

macrumors regular
Original poster
Oct 17, 2010
190
49
I'm not fond of how Apple does the SD card slot on their MacBook's! Why is the slot designed, so the card can only slide in 1/3 of the way in? I would much prefer a card that can be completely inserted into the MacBook so it can't be seen (that works off of a spring design), when you want to eject it, you push in and it pops out. Some people want to expand storage permanently, we don't want to see a card sticking out of our MacBook's, Apple!

Yes I know this is a form of feedback, which I've already sent into Apple. I was just curious what other users here thought?
 
Why is the slot designed, so the card can only slide in 1/3 of the way in?
Because it would take triple the space internally to allow the card to slide all the way in? Though people would argue that space could be made to accomodate.

Maybe 2/3 is the average width of the human finger which is used to hold on to the SD card as it is being inserted or removed? Though your spring idea might work around that. But a spring mechanism might increase cost or decrease reliability.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saturn007
That is probably exactly why Apple designed the slot like that.
You could just install bumper bars around the MacBook itself to accommodate for the card sticking out and making it look naturalish. Would still cost a lot less than what Apple offers for SSD upgrades.
 
You can get SD cards that are shorter and specifically made to be flush with your MBP like THIS one. But for "extra" permanent storage I would go with an external ssd drive that will give better performance and stability and safety from losing data.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
You can get SD cards that are shorter and specifically made to be flush with your MBP like THIS one. But for "extra" permanent storage I would go with an external ssd drive that will give better performance and stability and safety from losing data.
Oh nice, I never knew they made those like that. Yes I have external SSD but I like a permanent solution for other files that can't fit on the internal SSD.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
You could just install bumper bars around the MacBook itself to accommodate for the card sticking out and making it look naturalish. Would still cost a lot less than what Apple offers for SSD upgrades.

Do they sell bumpers that thick for MacBook Pro?

The speed of the Transcend JetDrive Lite is so slow. I think it's pretty clear Apple doesn't want people upgrading the internal storage with a UHS-II/III card.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saturn007
See my issue for the extra storage is probably not what most of you are thinking. I need like an extra 1TB of storage to store vids on, not worried about speed of the SD card, I would just drag it over the desktop of the Mac and then use it. I'm just tired of all this external storage crap. I don't understand why Apple has to solder the SSD and RAM into their computers, let us upgrade if we want. Instead, they want us to upgrade at the time of purchase with ridiculous prices, I just irks me!
 
With such an SD slot design, Apple kills a few birds with one stone. People who are serious about SD storage won't use a JetDrive due to reliability concerns. They want a full-size professional or high endurance SD card. Speed is secondary.
 
See my issue for the extra storage is probably not what most of you are thinking. I need like an extra 1TB of storage to store vids on, not worried about speed of the SD card, I would just drag it over the desktop of the Mac and then use it. I'm just tired of all this external storage crap. I don't understand why Apple has to solder the SSD and RAM into their computers, let us upgrade if we want. Instead, they want us to upgrade at the time of purchase with ridiculous prices, I just irks me!

Apple do this to hard-bake their planned obsolescence into their unassailable line of products and to assure their customers, the ones hard-locked into their closed, garden ecosystem, have little choice other than to replace their existing Macs (unless their customers have the savvy to look into OCLP for extended support). This, plus cryptographically locking all internal components to the logic board, plus offering a near-limitless variety of products at the same time across many pricing points, are what companies do as they approach a monopoly.


EDIT to add: Laugh heartily, but you know the above to be a true and correct assessment of how Apple run their macOS-based hardware business. :)
 
Last edited:
Apple do this to hard-bake their planned obsolescence into their unassailable line of products and to assure their customers, the ones hard-locked into their closed, garden ecosystem, have little choice other than to replace their existing Macs (unless their customers have the savvy to look into OCLP for extended support). This, plus cryptographically locking all internal components to the logic board, plus offering a near-limitless variety of products at the same time across many pricing points, are what companies do as they approach a monopoly.


EDIT to add: Laugh heartily, but you know the above to be a true and correct assessment of how Apple run their macOS-based hardware business. :)
Actually, I don't know that. I'm not a Mac user, yet.
 
Actually, I don't know that. I'm not a Mac user, yet.

The Retina and TrueTrone LCDs are supplied by LG.

While LG have supplied displays to the market (and to Apple) for decades (and Apple, since at least 1999, but likely further back into the early PowerBook G3 days of 1996), Apple arranged, at the time the first retina displays for laptops were coming out, that LG be their exclusive supplier and, after a point (circa 2016, as memory serves) and that LG may not sell the retina LCDs to third-party vendors/distributors under any circumstance.

What this meant for the Apple realm is there are no parts available on the reseller market for replacing a failed/broken Retina LCD unless one goes to Apple exclusively. Which may be fine for a few consumers, but once Apple designates a Retina-equipped Mac as “obsolete” (it’s quite a list), there is no redress for repairing/replacing a failed/broken Retina display, short of cannibalizing another identical product (i.e., cannibalizing a 13-inch early 2015 MBP’s Retina display with a dead logic board, for your own early 2015 with the dead display).

Worse, sometime after Apple added the T2 security chip to all their Macs (for MBPs, this began with the Touchbar series of 2016), they began to use a method of cryptographic matching/mating/“pairing” of components within a Mac to only work on that Mac (a technology borrowed from iPhones and iPads). Which means, in a practical sense, were one to do a display swap similar to my 2015 example above, but with one of these newer models, the system may disable, say, the iSight camera on the replacement display, even though there’s nothing incompatible or amiss about its genuine provenance.

In effect, these moves by Apple can and do accelerate the cycle of sending otherwise fully functional products to the crusher years too early and out of end-users’ hands. Call them “disposable appliances”. It wipes out the secondhand uses market and incorporates the above-described methods to thwart upgrades, repairs, or even component replacements (note: link demonstrates this with iPhone 12, but the same function is now carried over to Macs).

Once more, this is what a company can do when they approach becoming a monopoly.

The above are considerations one ought to evaluate when looking at or shopping for a current Mac — especially so a laptop.
 
Last edited:
See my issue for the extra storage is probably not what most of you are thinking. I need like an extra 1TB of storage to store vids on, not worried about speed of the SD card, I would just drag it over the desktop of the Mac and then use it. I'm just tired of all this external storage crap. I don't understand why Apple has to solder the SSD and RAM into their computers, let us upgrade if we want. Instead, they want us to upgrade at the time of purchase with ridiculous prices, I just irks me!
I have a micro SD adapter in my 14" that sits flush with the case. 1TB storage added. Easy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drewps5co0tt
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.