Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Gibson88

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 25, 2006
960
148
United Kingdom
First off I can see this thread turning into a piracy discussion, so can we please not let that happen. I just want a answer to my question.

The trojan that was floating around with iWork and CS4, I understand SL has a warning against it if it's on your system.

So am I right in thinking (hypothetically) that if I downloaded a torrent of iWork or Photoshop CS4 I would be informed if one of these had the trojan?

Also if I again hypothetically installed either of these and they work fine with no notification for SL, my system is 100% sure to be trojan free? (from this torjan at least).

That is all, Thanks.
 
I suppose so, although I dont understand someone would download a modified version of iWork when you can download the trail and, well you can figure out the rest.
 
Mac's don't get a lot of viruses, but downloading from torrent sites is illegal. Just download the trial version of CS4 and then buy a serial number it will give you more satisfaction than getting it for free. No piracy discussion here. YES SIRRRR
 
I give you guys a tip. NEVER download apps from torrent sites. Same thing for cracks and keygens. It's so much easier to download a trial (almost all apps have trial nowadays), install it and the rest you can figure out. If there's no trial, buy the app instead. If you really need it, you're ready to spend money on that too.
 
I think what he is asking is,

will his system detect it?

Not rather he should do it or not!

in which case, I'd be curious to know IF the system is right and in fact does detect a trojan if one is present.JUST TO KNOW, not to pirate safer.
 
You won't be 100% safe. That trojan checking is a proof-of-concept from Apple, which is why they don't list it as a feature. It does not detect all variants of those trojans so you have pretty much the same risk as ever. New variants are continuing to be developed and it will not detect those either.
 
I think what he is asking is,

will his system detect it?

Not rather he should do it or not!

in which case, I'd be curious to know IF the system is right and in fact does detect a trojan if one is present.JUST TO KNOW, not to pirate safer.

Thank you, I'm asking a question about SL not about torrents, someone could send me a folder full of legal JPG's and it could contain a trojan. So I want to know where I stand.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.