Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is RedSn0w able to JB OS 3.1.3? I thought not and that I thought that is how they differed (at least).
 
Is RedSn0w able to JB OS 3.1.3? I thought not and that I thought that is how they differed (at least).

Spirit jailbreaks 3GS out of the box with 3.1.3. Redsn0w doesn't (yet)

Edit: I misread the phone type. Since it's a 3G Redsn0w will jailbreak a 3G with 3.1.3 (point Redsn0w at 3.1.2 IPSW)
 
Definitely redsn0w, if your willing to spend the extras 1 minute. Then redsn0w is safer and waaay better.
 
Definitely redsn0w, if your willing to spend the extras 1 minute. Then redsn0w is safer and waaay better.
what are you basing the fact redsn0w is safer on?

end of the day they both as good as each other, they both serve different purposes.

Redsn0w - for 2g & 3g iPhones/1g & 2g iPod Touches upto 3.1.3
Spirit - all devices on 3.1.3 allowing untethered jailbreak for 3Gs
 
Redsn0w is preferable for a 3G because it uses a lower-level exploit which cannot be so easily patched by Apple. The userland exploit used by Spirit could easily be undone by a future version of iTunes without even a firmware update.
 
Yeah, Spirit is just for 3GS customers on 3.1.3. It serves no real benefit to 3G and lower.
it works on all devices including iPad all gen iPod Touches and iPhones it's biggest advantage is the simple one click jailbreak..... the one click jailbreak is a benefit to all for a hassle free jailbreak.

But as above it's a userland hack which can be fixed by apple
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.