The only issue is that if you submit a claim early on (say 3 months of coverage), you've used up your $100 but if you have monthly payments, you only wasted basically $18. Am I thinking correctly here?
Get Applecare for another year on Amazon or Ebay for about $35 and be done with it.
One is $100, the other is $288.
How did you come up with $288. It's $5.99 a month for 24 months. So that's $100.00 vs $143.76 by my calculation.
Also apple care does not cover accidental damage and squaretrade does.