Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

kingkezz

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 22, 2006
139
0
I'm slowly building my edit suite. Next on the list is some good quality monitor/studio speakers. I was just wondering what you guys use or reccommend for playback.
 
kingkezz said:
I'm slowly building my edit suite. Next on the list is some good quality monitor/studio speakers. I was just wondering what you guys use or reccommend for playback.

If you have a pair of speakers thay you already own and are keen on, consider the Sonic Impact T-Amp. Here are a couple of reviews. TNT-Audio and 6 Moons Audio. I had mine remounted in another container. Here are some others who have done this. diyAudio
 
I think the best help you can give us is a price range that you expect to purchase within. Audio qualtiy is extremely subjective, and you'll get a whole host of replies illustrating that.

So, what price range are you looking in?
 
I use Alesis Monitor One Mk2 Actives, I'm pretty happy with them though they show up the hopeless acoustics in my room. They cost around £250. Suggestions greatly depend on you budget.
 
Hey -

I think it also depends upon what you're going to be using them for. I've had a pair of Yamaha NS10Ms for 10+ years. They aren't the loudest, but they are crystal clear in the middle register at moderate volume - perfect for composition/arranging in a smallish studio.

Sound is such a personal thing, too. You should perhaps use this board to get some ideas....but you've got to hear them yourself.

And, of course, as others have said, price really matters.

MFK
 
RndmAxess said:
You can spend from a few hundred $ to many thousands$ on audio monitors.

Is this for a private edit workstation or a full edit suite with a producer's desk behind the editor?

It'll be for a private edit workstation.

michaelrjohnson said:
So, what price range are you looking in?

Anywhere under $AU500

jazzmfk said:
I've had a pair of Yamaha NS10Ms for 10+ years

I've heard good things about these. What do people think of them? How much do they cost?
 
I don't have any personal experience, but I've heard that M-Audio monitors are pretty good for the price, which should be in your budget.
 
howinson said:
tannoys would be good

I second that!

I have Tannoy Reveal 8D's and they are great. Nice for listening to during extended periods of mixing - tight bass - great. The 6D's are also in this range and are more suited to your price range but I don't have experience with those.

Anoyone else had any experience with the Tannoy Reveal 6D's?
 
Do you think it's a bit of overkill on my behalf. All I really want is a good quality set of speakers which I can playback whatever is on my timelime in Final Cut.

Or are they necessary if you want to get serious about your sound?
 
Passive or Powered also

I got a set of passive KRK ST8's that have a very good and flat sound. They 6's have a muddy sound to them. The Rokits seem to be a very good value for a powered monitor.
 
kingkezz said:
Do you think it's a bit of overkill on my behalf. All I really want is a good quality set of speakers which I can playback whatever is on my timelime in Final Cut.

Or are they necessary if you want to get serious about your sound?

Well you know, Studio monitors are really only there to give an accurate reflection of the sound you're working with. The more you spend usually runds parallel to how accurate they are.

Hi-Fi speakers aren't accurate as the sound is coloured to make it sound more appealing. Expensive Monitors are important if you're a composer or a songwriter - or an engineer for that matter. For FC then you could probably manage with a good $200+ pair. How about Yamaha?
 
kingkezz said:
Do you think it's a bit of overkill on my behalf. All I really want is a good quality set of speakers which I can playback whatever is on my timelime in Final Cut.

Or are they necessary if you want to get serious about your sound?

Well. Yes and no. I'd recommend getting a halfway decent set, but really anything works as long as there's reasonable reproduction, with one caveat. Listen to your monitors. Play everything you own on 'em. Then do it again. Learn how they sound, and mix accordingly.

The advantage to transparent, expensive speakers is that they're easier to "learn," and when you use someone else's transparent expensive speakers there's not much of a learning curve. The disadvantage is that they can be hella-expensive.
 
rjstanford said:
Well. Yes and no. I'd recommend getting a halfway decent set, but really anything works as long as there's reasonable reproduction, with one caveat. Listen to your monitors. Play everything you own on 'em. Then do it again. Learn how they sound, and mix accordingly.


Yes! I agree compeletly. It's not only important to figure out how stuff sounds on them but also in the context of the room you've put them in (acoustics etc).
 
One day I would like to get a nice pair of studio speakers also...

For now I will have to settle with my Sound Stiks II.

Why not just get a good pair of studio headphones instead? They are cheaper and you don't have to take into consideration the room or other sound variables.
 
ammon said:
Why not just get a good pair of studio headphones instead? They are cheaper and you don't have to take into consideration the room or other sound variables.

I just can't use headphones for a long period of time, I find them uncomfortable and they make my ears' hot!
 
Mackie HR624

The Mackie HR624's will blow away anything else in their price range. I've listened to them up against many other worthy and more expensive competitors and they win or tie everything else in their price range.

If you want to learn way too much about why they win, let me know and I can explain in more detail.
 
Mackies, Genelecs, Tannoys, they're all good. What you'll also need are isolation pads for the bottoms and sound absorbing material on the back walls to minimize sound reflections.
 
pepeleuepe said:
The Mackie HR624's will blow away anything else in their price range. I've listened to them up against many other worthy and more expensive competitors and they win or tie everything else in their price range.

If you want to learn way too much about why they win, let me know and I can explain in more detail.

They look very nice, but US$500 for one monitor - I think I need to reassess and bring my head out of the clouds...
 
pepeleuepe said:
The Mackie HR624's will blow away anything else in their price range. I've listened to them up against many other worthy and more expensive competitors and they win or tie everything else in their price range.

If you want to learn way too much about why they win, let me know and I can explain in more detail.


sure anot ??
it boils down to personal preference,
 
for editing i would recommend krk v4 series 2. nice speakers and they editted spiderman 2 on them. they are about $250 USD each. but i know you could find them for $200 each on sale.

read a review on them, plenty of stuff off google. and better yet go listen to them. (and some others too)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.