Superdrive replacement

[kitp]

So, my UJ-857-C can't write DVD anymore. I need something cheep, but internal. I don't want to pay 170$ + delivery, so what can be else?
GSA-S10N on ebay for 99$? Not bad. Is it really fit?
What about something like Pioneer DVR K-06? I know it's bigger, but if I put off that black front thing?

 

[mgacam2]

If you have applecare take it to Apple. They should give you a free replacement if its not working for legitimate reasons. That is what I did with mine and my new drive is actually better then the original one; much quieter.

 

[kitp]

If you have applecare take it to Apple.

Of course I haven't...