Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
68,142
38,917


Apps that are distributed through alternative app stores in EU countries will need to submit to a notarization process that's similar to the notarization process for Mac apps. According to Apple, Notarization applies to all apps, and it is a process focused on privacy, security, and maintaining device integrity.

ios-app-store-notarization-eu.jpg

Apple is aiming to ensure that apps do not have viruses, malware, or other security threats, and that they function as promised without exposing users to "egregious fraud."

Notarization will check for the following:
  • Accuracy - Apps are required to accurately represent the developer, capabilities, and costs to users.
  • Functionality - Binaries must be reviewable, free of serious bugs or crashes, and compatible with the current version of iOS. Software or hardware cannot be manipulated in ways that negatively impact the user experience.
  • Safety - Apps cannot promote physical harm of the user or public.
  • Security - Apps cannot enable distribution of malware, or suspicious or unwanted software. They also cannot download executable code, read outside of the container, or direct users to lower the security on their system or device. Apps also must provide transparency and allow user consent to enable access to the system or device, or to reconfigure the system or other software.
  • Privacy - Apps cannot collect or transmit private, sensitive data without a user's knowledge or in a manner contrary to the stated purpose of the software.
The malware and virus portion of the notarization process will be automatic, but there will also be a human review to make sure that apps are functioning as advertised.

Apple plans to encrypt and sign all iOS apps intended for alternative distribution to ensure that users are getting apps from known parties and to protect developers' intellectual property.

Notarized apps will be double checked during installation to ensure that they have not been tampered with and that installation was initiated through an authorized web browser. An iOS app that is found to have known malware after it's been installed will be prevented from launching on a user's device and new installations will be revoked.

Compared to the App Store review process, Notarization will not check apps for quality or content. Apple's App Store rules do not allow for content that is "offensive, insensitive, upsetting, intended to disgust, in exceptionally poor taste, or just plain creepy," and this content guideline will not apply to apps installed through alternative stores.

Information from Notarization will be used for app installation sheets that will be presented to end users. Apple will offer at-a-glance information about apps and their functionality that users can review before deciding to install an app through an alternate app store.

According to Apple, the Notarization system is aimed at providing "basic protections" that will reduce "some of the new risks" that are created by alternative app distribution. Apple says that it will not set the "same high bar for privacy and security" as the App Store review process.

Article Link: This is How Notarization Will Work for iOS Apps Distributed Through Alternative App Stores
 
Apple managed to put a leash on apps that have nothing to do with their services or distribution platforms… they managed to impose controlling/ownership claim on software that has nothing to do with them.

Very nice. I’m impressed… I’m not surprised, but I’m impressed.
 
So, side loading is the App Store without the Apple Logo? I imagine this will be short lived. They’ll be forced to do this in a normal way.

Could users install crap? Sure, but they can do the same on their Mac and the world hasn’t imploded
 
Last edited:
So, side loading is the App Store without the Apple Logo? I imagine this will be short lived. They’ll be forced to do this is a normal way.

Could users install crap? Sure, but they can do the same on their Mac and the world hasn’t imploded
I know, right? It's crazy how people just conveniently ignore that we've had safe and fairly open platforms for literal decades with no real issues.
 
I don't understand why just for Europe. I mean I do understand, but they already created this system.

I fail to see any real downside, it's just like on the Mac, just like what we asked for. It's practically indistinguishable from App Review except they aren't allowed to be quite as petty (in theory.)

I really, really don't like this fracturing. I want to see this come to all regions. First the SIM card, now the new rules in the US, different rules in the EU. All so that Apple can do the bare minimum required instead of coming up with reasonable concessions on their own.
 
So, side loading is the App Store without the Apple Logo? I imagine this will be short lived. They’ll be forced to do this in a normal way.
Exactly that. It is almost indistinguishable from the regular App Store, both in terms of the developer experience and restrictions, and Apple taking a cut of developer earnings. This is unlikely to fly with the EU.
 
Exactly that. It is almost indistinguishable from the regular App Store, both in terms of the developer experience and restrictions, and Apple taking a cut of developer earnings. This is unlikely to fly with the EU.
But there’s no commission. What cut?
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMac89
Look at that. Checking for safety and security without an app store monopoly. What was impossible yesterday is possible today.
No one knowledgable said it was impossible if Apple was still in the loop.

This is not side loading and it's not independent app stores. Those would require no influence from Apple at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMac89
Exactly that. It is almost indistinguishable from the regular App Store, both in terms of the developer experience and restrictions, and Apple taking a cut of developer earnings. This is unlikely to fly with the EU.

I don't think so either. My guess is this has been devised in a way that doesn't compromise any potential defence in a US antitrust case which is rumoured to be imminent.

If they walk all the policies back in Europe they will rolled over by regulators in the US and possibly elsewhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gusmula
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.