Just made this baby announcement. I am fairly new to digital media editing and have always been interested in photography. My wife is a fan of this, but it's just not exciting to me. Any critiques would be welcome...

I think you may be missing the point, note the birth weight, it's only 3lbs 4oz and thus Elliott is most likely a preemie or a very low birth-weight baby (or both and hence his "tiny parts").No offense but it looks creepy.
....I would rather see a traditional photo to show the context of size. Showing body parts doesn't portray size.
Definately needs scale, like a tiny hand holding your finger or something. Anything to make it look softer is nice too.![]()
I think you'd get more depth if you photograph the body parts in a different angle, not just head on/straight. Open up your aperture, try shooting in AV mode if you're not used to manual yet.
I find the whole black theme a bit too harsh, I think of babies and pastel colours, but hey what does your wife think? Is she happy with it all. I agree with others that the crops of some of the pictures are not great - especially the mouth and nose.
I think I'd go with a foot, hand and face nothing else needed.
Black isn't a great colour to chose, as others have said, it's a funeral colour, it looks nice and "artsy" but it still gives off the wrong message.
Please don't take any of these posts as being needlessly negative, if you're new to photography then expect feedback that you don't always want to hear, but run with it and you'll hopefully get a better project out of it
Btw, if it's your baby, congratulations, I wish you all the best![]()
try to add one of Elliot smiling ... that one reminds me a bit of a mug shot![]()