Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

DarkJaye

macrumors member
Original poster
May 11, 2009
85
2
Been with Apple since the 3G iPod but I finally got around to picking up a Mac about a month and a half ago. Love it, glad I made the jump, etc etc.

The inclusion of Time Machine pushed me to seriously consider using it, since up until this point I've never really bothered backing up my data due to lack of motivation to setup something similar on Windows (never experienced a HDD crash, *knocks on wood*). Anyway, I was reading up on backup solutions like Time Machine and I read a number of pieces saying the author uses Time Machine for the convenience of incremental backups, but also keeps a bootable clone on hand in case things get messy.

I was in the middle of setting up an external drive to have both (a bootable partition the same size as my mini's HDD, with the rest of it for time machine) when I started thinking about it and wasn't sure the bootable clone was all that necessary, especially since they would be sharing the same drive.

So I'm wondering what your thoughts are on all this, and how some of you have your backup solutions setup? Does it sound like overkill to you too?

PS. New to Mac Rumors and had issues finding the best place to put this post. I'm relatively new to the mac, and this discussion seemed to be basic enough, so I landed here. If there was a better forum suited to this kind of discussion, let me know.
 
Aloha DarkJaye, and welcome to the Forums.
I’m sure you will receive more knowledgeable responses than mine.
Overkill? No. But I wouldn’t put both backups on the same drive. The old “eggs in one basket” saying comes to mind. I’ve been using an older pre-Intel iMac G5 and just purchased a new iMac. When I checked the backups (not Time Machine) I had previously done, I found that on one of my HDs all the files were corrupt, and unusable, so I checked my second back up HD only to find it has failed:( Luckily I had a Third HD which appears fine. I know my case is rare, but...
 
Oh agreed, if I had another drive I'd keep them separate, but at the moment I don't and I'd rather not buy another one quite yet.

Thanks for your replies guys. I'll keep my bootable backup partition, sounds like the convenience is worth the space.
 
Like most of the others, I keep both a clone and Time Machine. I have them on the same FireWire drive. I am not too worried about them being on the same drive, since it is still separate from my running system drive.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.