Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

hzamani

macrumors member
Original poster
May 1, 2010
97
0
Hey all,

I was wondering if the upgraded ram in the mbp and firewire + sd slot, is worth the extra money than buying the recently updated macbook?

Thanks,

-Hamza
 
comparing a 4GB MacBook ($1099) and the base model 13"MBP ($1199)

the only difference are:
aluminum body
firewire and SD slot
and backlit keyboard

so, if you want the above features and the potential compatibility of 8GB ram for $100, you go for the MBP

if you're happy with 4GB of ram and polycarbonate body, go for the MacBook
 
I don't see the point in a backlit keyboard. I never look at the keys day or night when I type.

i wasn't trying to say the backlit keyboard is a necessity for everyone, but in my case i find it very helpful. i recently got the Mac so i'm still getting used to the somewhat different keyboard layout
 
comparing a 4GB MacBook ($1099) and the base model 13"MBP ($1199)

the only difference are:
aluminum body
firewire and SD slot
and backlit keyboard

so, if you want the above features and the potential compatibility of 8GB ram for $100, you go for the MBP

if you're happy with 4GB of ram and polycarbonate body, go for the MacBook

Although the Apple store doesn't offer an 8GB RAM upgrade, the MacBook DOES support it. There are a few threads floating around on this topic.
 
Hey all,

I was wondering if the upgraded ram in the mbp and firewire + sd slot, is worth the extra money than buying the recently updated macbook?

Thanks,

-Hamza

To me MBP is the easy choice for the following reasons:

If you open Safari and a few tabs, your 2 GB is pretty much gone. 4 GB is really the minimum that you did to do anything reasonable. That alone makes the price difference only $100.

The case, lighted keyboard and reader are certainly worth another $100.
 
MBP for sure, for the points outlined above..

Trust me you will regret it down the track, the MBP is a fantastic machine!
 
mbp
signature_BlueFaceGlasses-98213.jpg
simply for the 8gb ram limit rather then 4
 
We were talking about MacBook which officially supports only 4GB but 8GB works fine

oops my bad, shows how good i am at reading stuff properly :rolleyes: i think that if you don't really need the SD or Firewire ports then the extra $ for the Unibody might seem excessive if you are not really that bothered about it, personally i would go for the Unibody because the Aluminium Chassis feels great (even on the MBA) and that 3/4 years down the line when it starts to feel old, the extra Non-Warranty Voiding Official RAM can greatly improve your computing speeds for another year or two
 
I don't see the point in a backlit keyboard. I never look at the keys day or night when I type.

At night time its a God send to me to see the keys illuminated with the easy view.

I remember on the old white macbook it was a pain in the ass to look at the keyboard everytime before typing.
 
The MBP is probably worth it for the upgraded ram and the fact it has an aluminum chassis alone. Although it depends on your budget and you may actually prefer the plastic chassis to the aluminum.
signature_silverapple.jpg
 
That shows what a terrible OS MacOS X is. ;)
My X340 has only 2GB with Win7 and I can open couple of browser, iTunes, WinLive Mail and others and no problems at all. :D

Yeah, you keep thinking that.

Guess what, that memory can be relocated. *GASP* Can you imagine that?! Guess not.

OS X uses all the resources you throw at it, and if it runs out of room it trims it down as necessary.

Jeez, I make it on 768mb of RAM with Leopard running Safari and Quicktime and iChat and Mail, NO problem with the Forum Spy and ten tabs open.

Google is free.
 
Yeah, you keep thinking that.

Guess what, that memory can be relocated. *GASP* Can you imagine that?! Guess not.

OS X uses all the resources you throw at it, and if it runs out of room it trims it down as necessary.

Jeez, I make it on 768mb of RAM with Leopard running Safari and Quicktime and iChat and Mail, NO problem with the Forum Spy and ten tabs open.

Google is free.

I was being sarcastic, if you read the whole thread (especially Penn Jennings's post), I guess it gets more clear. I thought my smiles were enough.

Sorry for any confusion.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.