It seems my MBpro doesnt run on USB2 speed while copying from an external hdd with NTFS. It takes like 14 minutes to copy 4GB, while this should be a couple of minutes. Any suggestions?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
USB 2 speed on external hdd?
- Thread starter Zillion
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
First, what drive? What enclosure? Perhaps the problem is enclosure, rather than MBP.
Second, you mentioned 4GB of data, was this a small number of big files, or rather several thousand small files?
Second, you mentioned 4GB of data, was this a small number of big files, or rather several thousand small files?
USB transfers should be about 10-30MB/s, more on the lower end of that.
I have a hitachi external that does about 10/second. Not great, but decently faster than thumb drives I have.
I just got a fw800 enclosure, 50/sec! thats 3GB/min
if its a lot of small files, it will go slower too, opposed to one large one.
I have a hitachi external that does about 10/second. Not great, but decently faster than thumb drives I have.
I just got a fw800 enclosure, 50/sec! thats 3GB/min
if its a lot of small files, it will go slower too, opposed to one large one.
FW800 definitely trounces USB 2.0.I just got a fw800 enclosure, 50/sec! thats 3GB/min
FW400 is much faster as well.
Hi
Its a LaCie Hard Drive 320 GB USB
It concerns a DVD image with a small number of big files.
If I copy the files from a PC to the Hard Disk it takes a couple of minutes. When copying to the Macbook Pro it takes 14 minutes.
Hmm, dunno - maybe it's an issue with reading the NTFS format. I know Macs CAN read it but whether or not they're any good at it is another story.
Also, USB 2.0 is going to be inherently slow anyway, Firewire 400 and especially 800 are much faster than USB 2.0.
Were you doing anything else at the time on the MacBook Pro? USB 2.0 speed is often dependent on the processor as, unlike Firewire, it doesn't have it's own controller. If you were doing a bunch of stuff on the MBP it would have slowed transfer speeds down considerably.
Also, USB 2.0 is going to be inherently slow anyway, Firewire 400 and especially 800 are much faster than USB 2.0.
Were you doing anything else at the time on the MacBook Pro? USB 2.0 speed is often dependent on the processor as, unlike Firewire, it doesn't have it's own controller. If you were doing a bunch of stuff on the MBP it would have slowed transfer speeds down considerably.
Reinstalling Macfuse and latest NTFS-3G has solved this problem. Now copying is blazing fast again... 4.32 GB from external hdd to MacbookPro in less than 4 minutes
Reinstalling Macfuse and latest NTFS-3G has solved this problem. Now copying is blazing fast again... 4.32 GB from external hdd to MacbookPro in less than 4 minutes
Why are you using Macfuse AND NTFS-3G---use one or the other, not both.