Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Value in High end vs Low end MBP C2D

F

fred_garvin

macrumors regular
Original poster
Apr 6, 2003
102
49
I'm comparing the two MBP models and the upgrades to the 2499 model don't seem like much value for $500. If that model had the 160 Gig hard drive, I'd go for it, but with a stick of ram being $175, that's $325 for just a tiny CPU boost and some vram.

I don't game much at all on the notebook. Is there any need to the extra vram?

For Leopard effects, ala Time Machine?
For driving a 30" monitor? (I know both will, but will the low end MBP drive that monitor poorly/slowly)

I am a programmer. Only video/graphics I do is in iLife.
 
fred_garvin said:
I'm comparing the two MBP models and the upgrades to the 2499 model don't seem like much value for $500. If that model had the 160 Gig hard drive, I'd go for it, but with a stick of ram being $175, that's $325 for just a tiny CPU boost and some vram.

I don't game much at all on the notebook. Is there any need to the extra vram?

For Leopard effects, ala Time Machine?
For driving a 30" monitor? (I know both will, but will the low end MBP drive that monitor poorly/slowly)

I am a programmer. Only video/graphics I do is in iLife.
Click to expand...

Low end will suit you fine. The extra VRAM comes in handy when driving a display AND playing games on it as well. Aperture also does better with extra VRAM. Otherwise nothing major.
 
Hey Fred-
Given what you do, chances are that you probably will never have use for the higher-end GPU. Unless you're really into gaming, or, as me, into image analysis (large tiff stacks), you won't need it. Get the lower-end MBP, and, if you need it later on, get another stick of RAM from Crucial. You won't notice a difference in it driving a 30".
 
bought the low-end. will use the $500 i saved to buy more RAM and other goodies. more vram and .17ghz just doesn't cut it.
 
Hey fred. I am a developer/student. I bought the low end with the 160GB HDD. I'll throw in a gig of RAM in a month or two. I don't game much, but when I do, the 128MB should be more than good enoough for me. I say go for the low end and spend the diffrence on RAM and a good case. Cheers
 
The Shady said:
Hey fred. I am a developer/student. I bought the low end with the 160GB HDD. I'll throw in a gig of RAM in a month or two. I don't game much, but when I do, the 128MB should be more than good enoough for me. I say go for the low end and spend the diffrence on RAM and a good case. Cheers
Click to expand...

I totally agree with you. Definitely a good idea :)
 
The Shady said:
Hey fred. I am a developer/student. I bought the low end with the 160GB HDD. I'll throw in a gig of RAM in a month or two. I don't game much, but when I do, the 128MB should be more than good enoough for me. I say go for the low end and spend the diffrence on RAM and a good case. Cheers
Click to expand...

Unfortunately, without a student discount, I can't justify buying direct from Apple and doing a CTO.

If I buy from Amazon or MacConnection:

No Sales Tax, save ~$150
Mail in Rebate, $150
3% Amazon CC rebate or free Parallels ($60 - $75 value).

http://www.pcprices.net/macbookpro.shtml

So that $100 HD upgrade comes in at $460 instead. (MacConnection even stocks the glossy as a stock model for people who want that.)

OWC offers a rebate when you buy a new HD and send them the swapped out (Brand new) Apple HD. If only the new MBP had the easy swap hard drives that the MB has.
 
If I have the lower end MacBook Pro with 1.5GB of RAM do you guys think it will play Second Life (the game) well on a 30" ACD? I've been wanting to get one but this information has really started to scare me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back