I picked up the Speck Candyshell, and was surprised at how thin it was, especially compared to my wife's 4S with Candyshell case. I'm still not completely sold on the rubber edge around the screen. It's a little tough to put into a pocket, if you're wearing pants that aren't baggy, but I do like the rubber edge, since I can put it down and not worry about it sliding around. Overall I'm happy with the case. Build quality seems top notch. I got the glossy black case, since that's what Best Buy had (had a gift card), but wish they had the matte version, since mine's showing some scratches after only about 8 hours. Doesn't really bother me, since that's what a case is for, but I'd probably buy this case again, but in the matte version.