Looking to cut the cord, and would like to know what are the advantages of Apple TV over Amazon Fire Stick?
The ATV4K is the best streaming box imo. I own a few different one, but I have been a long time ATV fan.
ATV4K Advantages:
1.
Apple ecosystem
- If you are already in, this just makes things easier and better when compared to a Firestick.
2.
Power
- The ATV4K is very powerful, way more than it needs to be for just streaming. The Firestick's UI is slow, and laggy, but is perfectly fine once you select the content you want to watch.
- I would get the ATV4K over the slightly cheaper ATVHD (ATV4), with the A8 chip, the ATVHD was underpowered at launch imo, and is overpriced for what you are getting when the ATV4K is just slightly more expensive.
3.
IR
- All Apple TVs have built-in IR, which is nice if you want to use a different remote than the one it comes with. Many people prefer one remote for all, and having IR can help you get there. The Firestick does not have IR.
4.
Apps
- There are a crap load of apps for the tvOS, and not just streaming apps, but games, entertainment, education, shopping, and others. I wish there was better quality games, and the ATV4K is capable of having them, but that haste really taken off yet.
5.
AirPlay
- Airplay works great on the ATV, and while it is nice to have native apps rather than AirPlaying it, it is nice that it is an option if you need it.
ATV4K Disadvantages:
1.
Price
- Probably the biggest disadvantage, for many people that own an ATV4K, it ends up being an overpowered and overpriced Netflix and HBO streaming box. There are many other devices that can streaming Netflix almost as well for a lot less money.
- That fact is that you can buy many Firesticks for the price of one ATV4K. If you just plan on doing basic streaming, there are other devices that are much cheaper.
2.
Siri Remote
- Love it or hate it, there is a slight learning curve. It is missing a D-Pad, and in place is a touchpad that can make things difficult. I have been using it since the launch of the ATV4 in 2015, but it still annoys me sometimes.
- The design of it is a little strange. Even with the changes on the ATV4K, I still pick it up the wrong way. It is easy to lose, and is partially made of glass, so be careful not to drop it.
- If you plan on doing gaming, just get a capable controller, because unless it is a one click game, using the Siri Remote sucks.
- The Firestick has a more traditional style, other than not being capable of IR, and is much more natural to use.
3.
Missing features
- Browser for one, but some other things that are missing features like unable to Airplay a FaceTime call in widescreen, find my remote, unable to store media locally, no offlline viewing, no access to iTunes content offline even home movies or stuff you encoded yourself.... Just to name a few.
- The missing features from above, the Firestick is unable to do some of those things too, but when the ATV4K is priced where it is, I expect simple features like the ones I mentioned.
4.
Bugs
- The bugs have gotten a lot better since the launch of the tvOS, but there are still some annoying ones. It seems like to me, they are worse on the ATV4 than the ATV4K, maybe this is due to the underpowered A8 on the ATV4.
I am sure I am missing some things, if I think of something I will mention it.
You are talking about a lot of money if you get 3 ATVs, maybe consider getting an ATV4K for your main used TV, and Firesticks for the rest. You can always buy more ATVs later if you end up preferring them.