Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

gorbyno1

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Apr 29, 2010
5
0
hi,

I plan to buy a 15" MBP with a 500GB7200rpm HDD. Subsequently I wanted to replace the HDD with a SSD and put the HDD into the superdrive location using the optibay solution.

However it seems that it would be better to put a HDD that has a built in SMS feature (sudden motion sensor) in the superdrive location.

In order to find out if the 500GB7200rpm upgarde HDD offered at th apple site has the SMS feature of not, I need to know the brand/ model no. of the HDD.

Any clues.

regards,
Gorbno1
 

Seagate makes two versions of their 500GB 7500rpm HD, at least they did a few months ago when I picked mine up. One has the SMS the other, which is the one I got, does not. IIRC the version with SMS has an "X" at the end of the model number.

Any particular reason for putting the HD in the SuperDrive bay and the ssd in the HD bay? I left the HD in the HD bay and installed the SSD in the optibay.
 
Seagate makes two versions of their 500GB 7500rpm HD, at least they did a few months ago when I picked mine up. One has the SMS the other, which is the one I got, does not. IIRC the version with SMS has an "X" at the end of the model number.

Any particular reason for putting the HD in the SuperDrive bay and the ssd in the HD bay? I left the HD in the HD bay and installed the SSD in the optibay.

are you able to run the ssd as the main hd when it is in the optibay?
 
I'd say don't get one that has the SMS. No matter where it goes it'll mess with the built-in one and cause things to get sluggish.
 
Seagate makes two versions of their 500GB 7500rpm HD, at least they did a few months ago when I picked mine up. One has the SMS the other, which is the one I got, does not. IIRC the version with SMS has an "X" at the end of the model number.

Any particular reason for putting the HD in the SuperDrive bay and the ssd in the HD bay? I left the HD in the HD bay and installed the SSD in the optibay.

My Version of the 7200.4 with SMS has a G (for G-Force) at the end...

P.S. you can always disable the mac sms if you have a drive with sms
 
Thank you

Hi everybody,

Thank you so much for all the answers.

Bob...it never crossed my mind to put the SSD in the optibay....that sounds simpler..then I dont have to get into this sms thing....what would be the advantage/ disadvantage of putting the ssd in the optibay.

Cheers,
Gorby
 
Hi everybody,

Thank you so much for all the answers.

Bob...it never crossed my mind to put the SSD in the optibay....that sounds simpler..then I dont have to get into this sms thing....what would be the advantage/ disadvantage of putting the ssd in the optibay.

Cheers,
Gorby

I dunno if it's fixed in the 2010 MBP's, but my 2008 Unibody cannot hibernate to a SSD in the optibay, only when it's in the regular HDD bay.
 
Has anyone who has installed the Seagate 500GB 7200RPM...

Had any issues with the free fall protection or g-force when installed on a uni-body macbook pro?

I ordered the one without the free fall profection or g-force and i was curious if i should exchange it for the "G" model...

Has anyone encountered problems with either type of this drive?

I've been doing some reading on some other forums where people have been some difficulties with this drive and uni-body macbook pros.

I will be installing this on a i5 15.4 2.4 Ghz Macbook Pro Released in the second week of April...

Any Advice?

Thanx,

Greg
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.