As you see in sig, I have both. I love them both. Each has it's rightful place, for instance: The Nano is great for alsmost everything, and will impress anyone who hasn't seen one on the street yet, but the shuffle is a seemingly indestructible way to carry a good chunk of your favorite iTunes around whatever you do, and wherever you go. To sum up, I wouldn't want to schlep my Nano, (or my 4G photo) down the road with me on the chopper, but the Shuffle can always be found in my pocket, serving up the songs I just can't go anywhere without. Obviously 2 iPods are better than one. If you need a tiny tank, go Shuffle, but if the features of the Nano are what you crave, get it first. Later you must remember to get a refurb shuffle since it is only around $50 USD.