Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

crustyjugglers

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 23, 2009
7
0
It's pretty self explanatory but I had a repair for a MBP and they're going to replace the logic board. Am I going to get a better CPU etc. or just the same again? Also why would they bother to do this in the first place? My MBP must have failed the stress test or perhaps they're just pulling an Apple and giving a customer random freebies. Thanks!
 
It entails a new (or refurb) logic board that contains the type of CPU and GPU. There will be no upgrade to CPU or GPU.
 
what year is your MBP? I had a '11 MBP and apple replaced it after 3 failed logic boards. There have only been guesses as to why those boards were failing but no one knows for sure.
 
what year is your MBP? I had a '11 MBP and apple replaced it after 3 failed logic boards. There have only been guesses as to why those boards were failing but no one knows for sure.

You did pretty good, I've had 6 replaced with my 2011. Any 82-202 series boards crappy soldering like saturnotaku mentioned.

Not to be nosey. Did they give you a purchase credit towards a new laptop?
 
You did pretty good, I've had 6 replaced with my 2011. Any 82-202 series boards crappy soldering like saturnotaku mentioned.

Not to be nosey. Did they give you a purchase credit towards a new laptop?
The apple store I was at, took my old laptop and gave me like 1600 credit and then made the new MBP the same price, so it was just an exchange.

----------

Actually it's pretty well known that it's shoddy solder on the GPU that's causing 15- and 17-inch 2011 MBPs to fail.

Some people say its the ****** solder without lead and other people say its from the horrendous application of thermal paste. And that is why I kept my answer ambiguous. But I agree, its the excess heat and the ****** solder that is leading to the GPU issues
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.