Neogaf considers itself one of, if not, the premier gaming forums around. As such things are a bit "uptight" around there.
I agree with the no free email policy though as it cut down on spammers. But the registration process is a bit slow. They let new users in mass a few times a year, so when you register you have to wait.
Honestly, I think things could be a little better over there but "the powers that be" will hear nothing of it.