I actually prefer selling stuff on Craigslist these days. For one, it's local, you don't have to deal with the shipping and online payments. Second, you pick your set price, and more times than not, someone WILL buy it for the asking (as long as it's not completely unreasonable). And third, it's a quick transaction once you find a buyer. Cash on the spot.
With eBay, if you started at $185, and hoping it might close at $300, it may not reach that high. So you could be losing out. But at the same time you could go over $400. It's a gamble. As I said with Craigslist, you set the price, either they buy it or they don't. But someone always does.