Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LoganT

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Jan 9, 2007
2,382
134
It seems that whenever I uninstall an application, there is always an empty folder of the program I uninstalled in Library>Application Support and possibly others. Why wouldn't OS X delete those automatically after I uninstalled them? They obviously don't take up too much space cause it's just an empty folder, but why doesn't os x automatically delete it?
 
youre not uninstalling the application you are just moving them to the Trash i presume? some applications that use installers provide a uninstaller or script.

AppCleaner provides a feature called SmartDelete that monitors the Trash and searches for an application's other filess if dragged to the Trash.
 
youre not uninstalling the application you are just moving them to the Trash i presume? some applications that use installers provide a uninstaller or script.

AppCleaner provides a feature called SmartDelete that monitors the Trash and searches for an application's other filess if dragged to the Trash.

Well, I use AppZapper. I believe it deletes the stuff inside the folder like the .plist file, but doesn't delete the folder it was contained in. It might be for security reasons.
 
AppCleaner is free, I'm going to try it out. People on iusethis.com say it's better than AppZapper.
 
It seems that whenever I uninstall an application, there is always an empty folder of the program I uninstalled in Library>Application Support and possibly others. Why wouldn't OS X delete those automatically after I uninstalled them? They obviously don't take up too much space cause it's just an empty folder, but why doesn't os x automatically delete it?

Maybe when someone re-installs an application they'd like to have their preferences and other files in tact? The majority of people would vote for application settings familiarity over the need to worry about how little space is occupied by such files.
 
While it would be possible to delete the settings files for the current user and the system, you would have to go into root access to delete settings for other users on the machine. Seems dangerous to me. Try AppZapper or AppCleaner (free) if you want the files for your own account and the system (if you have access) automatically.

How would OSx know what files an application has generated? App Cleaner keeps a database and is not perfect anyway.

From my experience it doesn't keep a database. When you drop in a .app bundle called "X Program" it searches your drive for all files and folders also called "X Program" and gives you the opportunity to any of them.
 
How would OSx know what files an application has generated? App Cleaner keeps a database and is not perfect anyway.
No database. I don't even think AppCleaner searches the entire drive either. It just removes the "app" file and then searches common library folders for ancillary files that may have been created. It won't for instance remove all the components of a complex install (like microsoft office if memory serves).

Removing an OSX app is still 100 times more reliable than Windows though.
 
Removing an OSX app is still 100 times more reliable than Windows though.
You can't beat drag and drop. The downside is the fact that apps start puking out various files in ~/Library and even in /Library. Regardless the stuff that's left around is typically harmless and easily removed either manually or using appzapper.
 
Regardless the stuff that's left around is typically harmless and easily removed either manually or using appzapper.
Yep. When uninstalling apps in my windows days it usually involved manual registry deletions, a prayer and a pint of whiskey.

With OSX, I could care less if a dead file is left behind every now and then. When I do find it though, chances are it's not needed (like a windows DLL file lurking in the system folder for example).

Life is much more simpler for me these days and I stay sober. :D
 
You can't beat drag and drop. The downside is the fact that apps start puking out various files in ~/Library and even in /Library. Regardless the stuff that's left around is typically harmless and easily removed either manually or using appzapper.

It may be harmless, but it can be annoying. The trial version of Coda left a workflow in my services menu which I can't figure out how to get rid of. Anyone have any idea how?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.