Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Trigeeks

macrumors member
Original poster
Nov 18, 2010
40
0
I have ordered both sizes, hoping the 42mm will look the best. I have tiny wrist, 138mm, but love chunky watches. I wanted to know if any gal with small wrist bought the 42mm. Thanks
 
I'm not gal but depends on the look you want. Goes for guy or girl, but easier for a girl to get away with wearing an oversized watch. Guys just look dorky in ill-fitting anything. If you want to look inconspicuous like any other watch than 38. If you want the geek-chic "hey I'm wearing an AW" look then 42.
 
I tried it on yesterday. Looked fine and not too big but also looked like something from an 80s sci-fi film!!
 
I have been on the fence between the 38 mm and 42mm. I ended up ordering the 42mm and am receiving it tomorrow. I don't live near an apple store so I haven't been able to try one on. However my daughter went to a store. She said I'm going to love the 42. I'll post tomorrow and let you know.
 
I don't think 42mm is that large. Any size wrist should be able to wear it. Plus the extra battery life is always a plus.

Not true. I have small wrists and the 42 makes me look like a caricature. Way too big and makes my wrist look even more diminished. It's why it's not a good look for a guy but a girl can get away with it.

Take a look at some of the try-on pics posted by people wearing a 42 w/ small wrists and you'll see what I mean. It looks ridiculous.
 
Not true. I have small wrists and the 42 makes me look like a caricature. Way too big and makes my wrist look even more diminished. It's why it's not a good look for a guy but a girl can get away with it.

Take a look at some of the try-on pics posted by people wearing a 42 w/ small wrists and you'll see what I mean. It looks ridiculous.

Pics are a lot different than real life. That is why people post that they are shocked how small they are when they see them.

Everyone has their own preference in style, and I think that anyone can wear the 42mm. My other watches range from 39mm to 49mm, so I am a fan of a variety of sizes.


Larger watches are currently in style, so it won't make you look less of a man.

Stallone with his 60mm Paneri says so
SlyExp28_zps710755db.jpg
 
Pics are a lot different than real life. That is why people post that they are shocked how small they are when they see them.

Everyone has their own preference in style, and I think that anyone can wear the 42mm. My other watches range from 39mm to 49mm, so I am a fan of a variety of sizes.


Larger watches are currently in style, so it won't make you look less of a man.

Stallone with his 60mm Paneri says so
Image

I agree pics can be deceiving but I've tried on the watch; seen others trying on the watches in real life. 42 looks stupid on guys with small wrists (140-160mm). I know some guys have zero fashion sense or don't care if they are wearing baggy pants, or maybe wear baggy pants as an anti-social statement, but they look silly none-the-less, just not in their mind.

Not really sure what you are trying to say about Stallone's watch. He doesn't have tiny wrists or arms and I'm pretty sure most here on MR are not of Stallone's je ne sais quoi either.
 
I have 150mm wrists and I want to show you that photos are very missleading.
First and second photo are both 42mm on the same 150mm wrist wirh the only difference: the distance of the camera whiletaking the photos.
oqV2FYu.jpg
 
I agree pics can be deceiving but I've tried on the watch; seen others trying on the watches in real life. 42 looks stupid on guys with small wrists (140-160mm). I know some guys have zero fashion sense or don't care if they are wearing baggy pants, or maybe wear baggy pants as an anti-social statement, but they look silly none-the-less, just not in their mind.

Not really sure what you are trying to say about Stallone's watch. He doesn't have tiny wrists or arms and I'm pretty sure most here on MR are not of Stallone's je ne sais quoi either.
Not your fashion sense does not equate to bad fashion sense
 
XBan, did you go try them on? I tried them on and preferred the 42mm on my 138mm wrist.
 
Not your fashion sense does not equate to bad fashion sense

It's not MY fashion sense; I'm a guy. I have none. But there is a difference between fashion sense and wearing clothes and accessories that don't fit right. I'm merely advocating that those who don't want to look like a clown buy the size that fits.
 
My GF ordered a 42mm. She tried mine on after I got it and it looks fine. She's pretty fashion-forward as well, and her daily wear watch is most often a 40mm or 41mm Rolex. She also often wears a 44mm Panerai and there's not a problem with it.

Same for my wife: extremely fashionable, liked the display size and felt there was nothing wrong with it being a little oversized* like some of her other watches.










*That's what she said ...

----------

I have 150mm wrists and I want to show you that photos are very missleading.
First and second photo are both 42mm on the same 150mm wrist wirh the only difference: the distance of the camera whiletaking the photos.
Image

That's an outstanding example of the illusion of size difference through just the photo angle/lighting/etc. :cool:
 
I received my watch 2 days ago. When I first tried the 42mm watch on I wasn't sure if I was going to like it. Now that I've worn it for a bit....I love it. It's not too big where it's annoying or uncomfortable. I actually forget that it's on. Would the 38 look better on my wrist...probably. I like the bigger watch face especially when I'm running and am trying to read stats or control the music app. My wrist is about 150 mm. I have the BSB and it's pretty comfortable.

----------

I think 42mm can look good on women. The woman featured by Apple's main webpage on Apple Watch (I think) is wearing a 42 mm. Especially if you are in athletic outfit, the 42 mm would work well.

http://www.apple.com/watch/christy-turlington-burns/

I believe she is wearing the 38mm. She had mentioned in one of her weekly journals about wearing a modern buckle. Those are only made for the 38mm.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.