How about a 3rd option between absolute love and absolute hate? The truth is that new products will come out with more/better features - be it from a competitor or a next gen iPhone.
I would have picked a less polarized option. I really like my phone, it is not perfect, but i have none of the major issues others report. I want some missing functionality that should be there, but that doesn't make me feel that i have been screwed and I should screw them.
Everyone had 15 days to return their iPhone, and everyone knows that first revs of a product have issues, so everyone had other options.
Additionally, why do people say that jailbreaking their iPhone voids their warranty? It is always possible to put the old firmware back, and since this is not any kind of hardware hack I don't quite agree. If you went in and said that your phone is acting flaky with Cydia, then Apple could turn you away, but if you walk in with Apple software/firmware, they have NO way of knowing you jailbroke your phone.
If it did turn into a brick, how would they know it was jailbroken? With DFU mode, you can bypass software issues and load Apple software every time.
What are these miracles products people are buying, that are leagues ahead of the iPhone?
I don't know about you, but I've bought many things for way more money that have given me way more headaches than the iPhone does or has.
But, please, enlighten us - What phone manufacturer(s) have "done the job properly" and released a bonkers nigh-flawless problem-free multi-function phone right out the gate?
You're kidding me right? You can't think of any phones that have had less problems at release than the iPhone?
How's about the N95? That was far more usable straight out of the box than the iPhone, and cost a he'll of a lot less too.
I wrote this whole thing out about what the iPhone does that the N95 doesn't from a content management perspective and UI perspective and software and everything else, but what's the point, you know? I'm not here to "convince" you of anything.
Here's the thing I guess -- the iPhone is a whole different animal than the N95 (or blackberry, or whatever else with lots of buttons and lights and tweakable everything and so on). If that's the kind of phone you're into, you're never gonna be happy with the iPhone homey.
What if it stops responding with the pineapple boot up? It isn't that easy. The return policy is 14 days and 10% restocking fee.