the iphone has been the most popular selling phone probably since its first gen release, it has the biggest and most lucrative app store, so consumers are apparently comfortable with the iphone screen size.
I agree that the iPhone was revolutionary and has a great number of sales to-date. AppStore...great. However, it has given up some of the smartphone market share in recent times.
What you say doesn't really have anything to do -logically or otherwise- with consumers comfort with the 'iPhone screen size'.
Large screen sizes have not really been a factor until now. Android's app market is doing well, and it's OS has improved quite a bit...now, add larger screens/multiple phone choices.
lets not get ahead of ourselves and act like the iphone screen needs a telescope to navigate...
the difference between apple and android screen size does not compromise the functionality of apple apps in the least bit IMHO... its always going to be a talking point b/c "bigger is better"... but sometimes performance, ease of use, efficiency, quality software development can trump a bigger screen..
I don't think myself and other folks are getting ahead of ourselves here. The first thing I did when I bought my first smartphone (a 3GS) was to find a good full-screen browser...so, I went with Perfect Browser. Why? because 3.5" screen with Safari's borders was not acceptable or EFFICIENT to browse and functionally deal with websites (I don't always want to deal with mobile layouts, and sometimes they can be quite limiting.)
That is but ONE example. Google Maps would be better and more viewable without their bar/borders as well, but hey...a larger screen would make that a moot point.
Typing...hard to see what I am responding to since the keyboard takes up the majority of the screen...larger screen would help. Videos...etc etc etc...
i could understand if the screen difference were that of the blackberry playbook vs the ipad, but the screen difference in phones is almost irrelevant.. unless you like the appearance of holding and looking at something bigger
How is it 'almost irrelevant'? And, again, the iPhone dimensions do not need to be much bigger for this to happen. If they are, it's not the end of days, it's not like we are pushing for the Galaxy Note