Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mac-jam

macrumors regular
Original poster
May 25, 2015
149
15
Would you rather have 1 x Pro Display XDR or 2 x Studio Displays and why?
 

Basic75

macrumors 68000
May 17, 2011
1,993
2,336
Europe
If those were my only options I'd take 2 x Studio. More screen real estate, and I don't like or need local dimming. But actually I wouldn't use either, ignoring the price, monitors with fans are just ridiculous for office use.
 

xraydoc

Contributor
Oct 9, 2005
10,818
5,289
192.168.1.1
Would you rather have 1 x Pro Display XDR or 2 x Studio Displays and why?
If I wasn't paying for it myself, I'd take one Pro XDR. I prefer one big display to two smaller ones, to be honest, even if I lose some pixels overall.

However, if I am paying out of my own pocket, I'd take two Studio displays (which is what I actually did). 2x ASD is still less than half the price of a single XDR.
I've got one in landscape and one in portrait. Works quite well, but I'd still prefer to be centered on one bigger display than slightly off center of two (I'm centered on the landscape ASD, with the portrait ASD to the left of the main landscape display).

If anyone wants to trade, I'm open to it (lol).
 
  • Like
Reactions: ShivneelSingh

Zest28

macrumors 68020
Jul 11, 2022
2,220
3,073
1 x Pro XDR because I don’t like multiple monitor support on Mac. You would think a software would open on the display you closed it last time, nope ….

Mac OS seems to have a mind of it’s own on where to place software on which display, which is why I would rather have 1 big display, than multiple smaller ones.
 

BeatCrazy

macrumors 603
Jul 20, 2011
5,001
4,338
I use one of each :)

But only for productivity work, I'm not a content creator. Side by side, you can tell the XDR is much more uniform, obviously has better contrast and color consistency.

I could probably live with single monitor, since I make heavy use of the Magnet app. So I'd probably go with "one XDR".
 

okkibs

macrumors 6502a
Sep 17, 2022
921
873
The XDR because I don't want to ever go back to displays without proper HDR support. And I'd get a small 15" USB-C companion screen off to the side, so that I can run apps in fullscreen on the main display and still have access to a chat window or a music playlist without interfering with the main content.
 

kitsunesoba

macrumors member
Jun 26, 2020
63
65
Depends on the user, in my opinion.

The way I work, I benefit from having two monitors, primarily because that enables me to have two independent sets of spaces that can quickly be switched between, which works very nicely for window management. The way I have things set up, I have a primary monitor where my current focus windows sit and a secondary one where secondary/auxiliary windows (chat, music, mail, etc) sit. It works well for switching contexts.

That said, the secondary display doesn't need to be something as nice as a Studio Display for that. In fact some cheap used monitor from your local Craiglist or hand-me-down from a friend will serve this purpose nicely. When I upgrade my my main display some time this year, the old Thunderbolt Display that's currently my primary will become my secondary.
 

JaredJenkinsDesign

macrumors member
Jul 19, 2022
97
79
If it's just between those two options, I'd likely go dual ASD for the cheaper cost, extra screen space and the fact that the XDR is a bit older and I don't necessarily need HDR support. Although like xraydoc said, if I wasn't paying for it myself and say my employer gave me the choice between these two, I'd go Pro XDR then.

If it's between one 32" 6K or dual 27" 5Ks, I'd probably prefer a 32" 6K now. Just hoping we get some more options in the near future since I'm not really digging the Dell U3224KB.
 

DennisdeWit

macrumors 6502a
Nov 16, 2016
820
780
The Netherlands
I am at the exact same choice. I don’t need HDR and I have a 34” now, which will be sitting next to the ASD’s in the near future. Given the fact the Pro Display XDR is 3 years old, it was worth the price 3 years ago. Now it is not. The two main reasons for me are a glossy screen and 218 ppi. I barely watch HDR content. If that’s the only difference, I’d go for the 2 ASD’s. More screen space. :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.