I agree with you, junking up MacOS with overlapping Windows functions is not the right answer to help Windows users on a Mac.
Do you also jump in and talk about helping Mac users when they try to stick to/emulate past versions of how their Apple devices work (like pre-liquid glass perhaps), or is your help reserved specifically for Windows-like behavior?
This whole post is about changing the way Apple devices work, and cluttering them up with software that help with this, so is all of that bad as it means that we're not using our Apple devices the Apple-designed way?
I've got BetterTouchTool to switch between tabs in ways that Macs can't do, I've got HazeOver to focus on front windows, I've got VLC to get a different UI playing videos, the way that I use virtual displays on Macs goes back to habits formed on Solaris in the 90s, and I buy all my keyboards in a heavier taxed region only because my muscle memory prefer that physical layout, and so on.
I could use any default configured Apple device as long as it's set to a language I at least sort of know, but it'd be slow work that'd make me all kinds of irritated. So, here's the question:
What's the difference between me doing my "pro setup" to get my preferred configuration, as compared to someone wanting functionality that just happens to be more like how Windows currently works?
Why is my pro stuff a good thing, while Windows stuff is negatively viewed? Why do you get the urge to "help" Windows users, but don't get the urge to "help" Mac users not change the defaults that Apple currently has set?