For what it's worth, my iPad 2 battery so far seems AOK compared to my original iPad.
However, I do think there might be some weirdness from 4.3 affecting battery life, as when I updated my iP4 the battery drained a bit fast for a couple days but with calibration, this had alleviated a bit.
I suspect we will see 4.3.1 at some point sooner than later and Apple will have dialed this in. Don't forget, Mossberg's iPad 1 was running iOS 3 and had a less demanding processor/GPU, etc.
Apple's claim was exceeded by most last time, this time it is spot on or in my case, maybe even a little better. 🙂