Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is there anything that Lightning is better at than USB-C?
Maybe you misunderstood me or I wasn't clear.

I said that despite lightning not having feature parity with USB c the EU should have let market forces play out which would have yielded the same result.

The result is important. The result is full adoption of usb c for Apple products. You can get the result by forcing government intervention or let natural market forces i.e. buying habits play out over time.

Do you not think that most Apple consumers wanted usb c adoption regardless of the EU? Apple would have caved to market forces as they have done in numerous similar cases in the past. Apple does u turns all the time and holds out on old tech all the time. It is all about numbers for Apple. Economics of scale are integral to Apple's success and using a hardware design and certain hardware components for a long time to get profits back from R&D etc. If you switch up this manufacturing success by arbitrary forcing hardware changes before Apple planned destroys the Economics of scale and duration of a copyrighted hardware design. Tinkering with business unless absolutely necessary never delivers good results.
 
Do you not think that most Apple consumers wanted usb c adoption regardless of the EU? Apple would have caved to market forces as they have done in numerous similar cases in the past. Apple does u turns all the time and holds out on old tech all the time. It is all about numbers for Apple. Economics of scale are integral to Apple's success and using a hardware design and certain hardware components for a long time to get profits back from R&D etc. If you switch up this manufacturing success by arbitrary forcing hardware changes before Apple planned destroys the Economics of scale and duration of a copyrighted hardware design. Tinkering with business unless absolutely necessary never delivers good results.
I think most Apple iPhone / iPad consumers don't know what either Lightning or USB is and many who do are indifferent to one or the other.

That said would Apple have caved to market forces? Perhaps, but I saw no indication they were planning to. USB-C had been widely used on other smartphones for years. Yet Apple kept plugging away with Lightning despite its inferiority. Likely due to licensing revenue Apple was collecting.

I am all about free market with limited government interference. But I don't think that the EUs single cable mandate (and that's what it was, I don't believe it was a USB-C one, but then I don't live in the EU) stifled any innovation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: navaira
I think most Apple iPhone / iPad consumers don't know what either Lightning or USB is and many who do are indifferent to one or the other.

That said would Apple have caved to market forces? Perhaps, but I saw no indication they were planning to. USB-C had been widely used on other smartphones for years. Yet Apple kept plugging away with Lightning despite its inferiority. Likely due to licensing revenue Apple was collecting.

I am all about free market with limited government interference. But I don't think that the EUs single cable mandate (and that's what it was, I don't believe it was a USB-C one, but then I don't live in the EU) stifled any innovation.

Apple went whole hog on MacBooks with USB-C back in 2016 while dropping Magsafe and a lot of people liked it and a lot didn't. So much so that they brought it back. So Apple is sensitive to market demand. We have Magsafe and USB-C charging so hopefully customers can like one or the other today. My iPhone 13 mini is the last device that I have still using Lightning. I have USB-C to Lightning dongles so it is not a huge problem with charging on the road. It is nice to just carry a few USB-C cables and a small conversion dongle. I have these for MicroUSB as I still have a few devices that use that and I even had a Mini-USB device that I use regularly. But dongles have made it possible to avoid the cable tangles in my bag.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.