Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

murri

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 13, 2014
11
0
Barcelona
Hello.

Like many others here, I replaced the optical drive on my late 2009 imac 27 with a samsung 840 evo, and placed the optical drive in a generic usb case (and is recognized as original apple hardware - I assume that makes it a Superdrive)

fakesuperdrive.png


After experiencing the read preformance degradation known with the 840 evo drive, I decided to update its firmware. The problem is, that there seems to be a firmware lock preventing any usb unit booting unless it complies with the following:

http://support.apple.com/en-us/ht1948

Which means that the ISO provided by Samsung cannot be used in this case. I have tried forcing the boot sequence from the cd i burned (also tried a usb stick, with same result) via refit, but would get an error saying "The firmware refused to boot from the selected volume":

1288442170.or.23380.JPG


So, what I ended up doing is installing bootcamp on a partition on the internal hdd. This task was dreadful with many hours of trial and error. As I had no way of booting a windows installer, the only way I managed to do so is running the installer using a virtual machine to write to the bootcamp partition directly. There are various guides on how to do this, but the one that worked for me is using Parallels.

Anyway, after finally installing bootcamp for the sole purpose of upgrading the ssd firmware, I found that the Samsung Magician software indicates that the firmware installed on the ssd is up to date :(, even though I made sure AHCI and SATA were configured correctly in Windows - lest that be a reason...

Capture1.PNG

Capture2.PNG

Capture3.PNG


So unless somebody else has succeeded using bootcamp to update the 840 evo, I would advise against the whole exercise.

Hope this might save someone else's time
 
Soooo why didn't you use the USB stick option from Samsung's website and just use a basic USB flash drive? Using the Mac Method?
 
Soooo why didn't you use the USB stick option from Samsung's website and just use a basic USB flash drive? Using the Mac Method?

Because its seems that on iMacs that originally had an optical drive, usb booting other than OS X is not supported - see screenshot below apple support link
 
evo 840 upgrade imac succeeded

Well, finally updated the firmware and ran the performance recovery tool. Seems all the hassle of installing bootcamp was worth it, as it allowed me to use syslinux to set up a small fat partition, where I dropped the contents on the samsung iso, and used rEFit to boot it.
 
Samsung Magician in BootCamp also reported the latest firmware had been installed for me, but the Performance Restoration Tool worked perfectly right in Windows which updated it to the latest version.

I'm not sure why it didn't work for you. :confused:
 
Last edited:
Samsung Magician in BootCamp also reported the latest firmware had been installed, but the Performance Restoration Tool worked perfectly in Windows which updated it to the latest version.

I'm not sure why it didn't work for you. :confused:

It would not continue because the filesystem was not NTFS (the last screenshot shows the error in red).

So whereas the ISO tool will redo any filesystem (must work at the raw level), the windows version only seems to accept NTFS, and will not even try apply the firmware upgrade (it should be seperate task)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.