Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I’m reluctant to use an open source password manager with all my data. That requires a lot of trust in people who have contributed to that platform - which is too risky for me.
With BitWarden you can choose to host your data yourself.
 
1Password is The Gold Standard of encryption when it comes to passwords for every site you ever visit. The Best!
I work as an applied cryptographer, `AES-GCM-256` isn't the "gold standard" of symmetric encryption.
When used properly with a per instance key, nonce tuple, its fine, but I would opt for XChaCha20-Poly1305 instead every time I reach for a stream cipher.

Their use of PBKDF2 instead of Argon2 as a password based key derivation mechanism is also questionable, lack of ASIC resistance etc.

Why do you think their choices are particularly good?
I can tell you I definitely wouldn't rely on 1Password.


There are other sub-optimal choices with regard to cryptographic primitives use by 1Password, like I said, it's fine (if you believe they implemented it all correctly), but it's not open-source.
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
Reactions: jinnj
I'm a long time user, but am finding 1P is becoming a bit annoying these days - their pop-up auto-complete boxes are often getting in the way, it often doesn't play nice with Keychain and for some reason it keeps asking me if I want to save new passwords that aren't new, they're already in 1P. I still find it useful for working between Mac and Windows, storing non-password related info and site that don't properly trigger Keychain, but Keychain now gives the better, more seamless experience in other circumstances IMHO.
 
I'm a long time user, but am finding 1P is becoming a bit annoying these days - their pop-up auto-complete boxes are often getting in the way...
A little disappointed to say I agree. I've regrettably turned off the Inline Menu option for Safari because it's too intrusive and because Keychain seems to be working better than ever. Still love 1P for its functionality and versatility, but this was a step backwards as far as I'm concerned.
 
That's not required. You can store it locally or on other cloud services.

However you're missing the point. You could store the vault(s) at evilmalware.com. They're encrypted; exposing them to adversaries is not scary because they can't do anything with them. So your concerns are unfounded.
No, I get that part, that the vaults are encrypted. It's just that since everyone knows 1password holds the vault I assume hacker will be more likely to attack it. I know that the chances of them cracking the encrypted vault is little to none, but its still a bit scary.
 


AgileBits today released a new version of popular password management app 1Password, with the updated Mac software now able to run natively on Apple's M1 Macs.

1password-apple-silicon-support.jpg

Version 7.8 of the 1Password app adds native support for Apple silicon, which is something AgileBits has been working on since Apple first debuted its newest machines. M1 support has previously been available in the beta version of 1Password.According to the release notes for the 7.8 update, the new software also includes multiple bug fixes and performance optimizations.

1Password 7.8 can be downloaded from the 1Password website at the current time, but it is not yet available in the Mac App Store.

Article Link: 1Password for Mac Updated With Apple Silicon Support
Sometime ago, communicated to 1PW support, I was experiencing memory release issue with v7.7. [After viewing saved docs within 1PW, Activity Monitor would report 1PW using 1GB + memory.] Albeit I've only been using v7.8 (on my iMac) for a short period, this issue appears to have been corrected. ...1PW continues great support and the app is a necessity on my iPhone 12 mini (& Watch 6 - opening 1PW), iPad Pro, iMac 27. I'm a subscriber and glad for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lysingur
I'm a long time user, but am finding 1P is becoming a bit annoying these days - their pop-up auto-complete boxes are often getting in the way, it often doesn't play nice with Keychain and for some reason it keeps asking me if I want to save new passwords that aren't new, they're already in 1P. I still find it useful for working between Mac and Windows, storing non-password related info and site that don't properly trigger Keychain, but Keychain now gives the better, more seamless experience in other circumstances IMHO.
I just turned off those functions.
 
Since lastpass will soon require a subscription if you want to use on both mobile and desktop, I'll have to check this out

Or, maybe I'll just go with bitwarden:
Yeah, Logmein strikes again. I used LastPass forever. Dumped it over their new policy and went with Bitwarden. Bitwarden seems to work just fine and the transition was very easy. Just download a .csv from LastPass and import to Bitwarden. I'm baffled by Logmein's thought process. They would have been better off just limiting the number of devices of any stripe for the free program, rather than something as ridiculously silly as making it PC or Mobile. But Logmein has done silly stuff like this before. It's amazing they are still around, chasing away their customers as they do when open source is available these days...
 
  • Like
Reactions: applicious84
I don't expect free software. However, if I can pay a one-time fee and get the same features that I was getting with 1Password, I will pay the one-time fee.

Mac users can still buy a single license for the 1Password standalone application for a one-time fee of $64.99. To purchase this version, you have to download 1Password 7 from the AgileBits website, then click "Need a license? We have those too" when prompted after opening the app for the first time.
 
I don't expect free software. However, if I can pay a one-time fee and get the same features that I was getting with 1Password, I will pay the one-time fee.
Any software that deals with security in this day and age can't possibly be a one-time fee. There have to be engineers that work on patches and updates, learn and build new tools, and assess and detect new risks. Hackers who create viruses, malware and ransomware don't rest, why do you expect your computer to be secure but only pay a one-time fee?
 
People are funny. They expect to get paid for their work but want other people's fruit of labour for free. If you can't shell out $3 per month for a password manager, you probably don't even care that much about your passwords to be needing a password manager in the first place. Most people have no idea how much goes into ensuring the security of a database, especially one that stores highly sensitive information. :rolleyes:
 
I could be wrong, but I don't think Keychain supports password generation -- which is a critical component of the others, especially with today's security vulnerabilities and having so many website logins to manage.
You are wrong. Browsers and apps that support Keychain functionality will offer randomly generated strong passwords which are subsequently stored in Keychain. If properly implemented, where an app and website share the same login credentials, Keychain can be made aware of this. This means that you can easily flip between app and website using the same credential, all securely managed by Keychain.
 
I could be wrong, but I don't think Keychain supports password generation -- which is a critical component of the others, especially with today's security vulnerabilities and having so many website logins to manage.
It does
 
I don't believe 1Password can do that but, Strongbox can.


Strongbox looks decent, however their lack of support for other than Safari browser plug ins and no windows support is a non starter for me.
 
It’s useless on Android, Linux, and Windows. Not to mention it’s crap. I don’t get why people say this all the time where there is a topic about passwords managers. There is a world outside of Apple.

I also can share passwords with family members very easily. My mom locked herself out of 1Password and with the family subscription, I can help recover her data. It also stores more than just passwords. iCloud Keychain is so limited and its just garbage.

This is why I’m more than happy to pay for the sub. My Muggle family needs 1P and they need me to be able to access their data if/when needed. We split the cost three ways. But even if it were just me I’d still pay. It’s more than worth it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr. Heckles
Any software that deals with security in this day and age can't possibly be a one-time fee. There have to be engineers that work on patches and updates, learn and build new tools, and assess and detect new risks. Hackers who create viruses, malware and ransomware don't rest, why do you expect your computer to be secure but only pay a one-time fee?
A one-time fee doesn't mean no updates. Strongbox is updated regularly. I am suppporting the developer. I paid what was asked. Why do you see that as a bad thing? Strongbox currently has over 100,000 users. They also offer a business option.
 
Strongbox looks decent, however their lack of support for other than Safari browser plug ins and no windows support is a non starter for me.
I can understand that. Have you emailed the developer about offering other browser support? I have found him to be very responsive.

As to Windows, that doesn't enter into my usage pattern.
 
People are funny. They expect to get paid for their work but want other people's fruit of labour for free. If you can't shell out $3 per month for a password manager, you probably don't even care that much about your passwords to be needing a password manager in the first place. Most people have no idea how much goes into ensuring the security of a database, especially one that stores highly sensitive information. :rolleyes:
It's not a matter of not being able to afford $3 a month, it's more so a matter of looking at the yearly subscription total being over $500 a year, and realizing that in some areas, I can reduce that total and still use quality software and support the developer at the same time.

Jut because a person stops using 1Password, that doesn't necessarily mean said person is cheap and doesn't believe in paying a developer for his or her work. There are other options besides 1Password that work very well.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.