Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Works great but not with the bumper on.

just pop the top off the new dock , cut off the well part of the top and put it back on - works fine with bumper...

a734e7ed.jpg
 
This is what i plan on doing to my old dock also as soon as i get my damn bumper which is on order from apple. I could care less on the looks as long as i can dock it and remove it with no problems.
 

this shop describes the 2g dock as:
GENUINE APPLE iPhone 2G (1st generation) DOCK

which is where my confusion comes from - not from my lack of ability to read the post

You asked, "will a 2g dock work?" The first post answered this.

BTW- I'm currently using my first gen dock with the iPhone 4 and like it a lot! I received the iPhone 4 dock in the mail (that I ordered on the 15th), and haven't opened it yet. I don't like how it covers up the front, while on the original dock, you can press the home button and such.
 
This is news? The first thing I did when I got home was to put it in my 1st gen iPhone dock because they two are so similar in shape. Works like a charm.
 
So I bought a (new) 1st gen holder off ebay from a hong kong store and my iphone doesn't fit too well in it. In fact, I have to push kinda hard to get the phone to make contact, much harder than it should be. I don't have the bumper case, this is just the bare iphone. Also, the square mark on the holder is above where you plug the cord in, but you have to plug it in upside down because that's the way the connector is mounted.

I opened it up and it's different from the pics someone posted here. Obviously some chinese knock-off of the real deal, so buyer beware.

I suppose I'll have to break out my dremel to make it fit in easily, or just use it without the plastic mounting. It's basically just a ciruit board with a connector at each end and an audio jack to one side.

Eh, but what can you expect for $6.99?

Followup: Just tried to use the Line Out audio jack. It doesn't work either. *sigh*
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.