I post on the forums, and I also own one. No problems whatsoever. As I said before, I'm also not keeping it to the age/mileage where it will become hideously unreliable, so that doesn't matter either.
Still don't care about it being fast, not sure what's so hard to grasp about the idea that someone looking at a 170 hp 5-banger with front wheel drive probably just doesn't care how fast it is. It's got enough passing power, and that's all that matters.
For $25k I get push button ignition with intelligent access key fob, heated sport seats, power seats w/lumbar, navigation, fender premium audio w/subwoofer, sunroof, leatherette, soft touch dash, ipod cable hookup, etc. etc.
You get exactly none of that with a $40k 3-series, except the leatherette and *maybe* the iPod hookup. Now that's a car that's way too expensive for what it is. From the looks of it, the Jetta SEL has a lot of bells and whistles for under $25k brand new. I don't know a whole lot of other new cars that come with that much stuff at that price point. The interior of the SEL is quite a bit nicer than the lesser, vanilla Jettas that you mostly see (S/SE). Is it the interior of a CC? No, but it isn't a $34k car either. Is it worse than prior Jettas? At the SEL trim all signs point to that being debatable, but I've spent time in the new SEL and it's certainly not beneath me. It's a perfectly nice interior as far as I'm concerned and I liked it just fine, and the price of the car doesn't break the bank.