Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iLikeTurtles!

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jun 22, 2012
439
0
I know its an off comparison but I have 2 options,

Keep my currnt 2011 anti glare 15" macbook pro (i upgraded the Hd to a intel 520 120gb SSD) and Buy an ipad 3

OR

Sell my current macbook pro and spend the extra on top for a retina macbook (extra would be around the price of an ipad)

What would you guys do?

I know it depends on needs, what ur gonna etc, but I am curious to what others would do if they were in my situation

thanks folks!
 
I know its an off comparison but I have 2 options,

Keep my currnt 2011 anti glare 15" macbook pro (i upgraded the Hd to a intel 520 120gb SSD) and Buy an ipad 3

OR

Sell my current macbook pro and spend the extra on top for a retina macbook (extra would be around the price of an ipad)

What would you guys do?

I know it depends on needs, what ur gonna etc, but I am curious to what others would do if they were in my situation

thanks folks!
I'd keep your MacBook pro and buy and iPad. I have a 2012 MBP hi-res antiglare and an iPad 3 wifi and it's a great combo. With your current MacBook you have a user replaceable HD, memory and battery.
 
I'd keep your MacBook pro and buy and iPad. I have a 2012 MBP hi-res antiglare and an iPad 3 wifi and it's a great combo. With your current MacBook you have a user replaceable HD, memory and battery.

I know this is a vague quesiton but, how do you make use of "both" devices?

Also i thought the battery on the retina macbook pro was replacable, jsut expensive to do from apple?
 
Battery, maybe, but memory and SDD is gonna be a real pain in the *ss... One of the reasons I just bought a 2012 cMBP...
 
I currently have this same combo and love it. I use my mbp for games and movies and schoolwork, and use my iPad for textbooks, browsing the Internet, and sending short emails. The iPad is also super convienient for travel.
 
I currently have this same combo and love it. I use my mbp for games and movies and schoolwork, and use my iPad for textbooks, browsing the Internet, and sending short emails. The iPad is also super convienient for travel.

regular macbook?
 
It always makes me laugh when people hate on the lack of upgradability on the new MBP. Aside from throwing an SSD in straight away, and upping the RAM, which are both things you do initially btw, its a non-issue for the majority of users.

Fair enough if you still use crappy mechanical drives (pointless given how dirt cheap SSDs are now), but in reality chances are you will never have to open up your MacBook after the initial upgrade.

My 7 year old iBook G4 is testament to that.
 
if u had to chose would u go retina macbook or 2011 macbook plus ipad?

Tough choice but I'd honestly stick with my current setup. I don't need a retina screen since I think my hi res is enough. The amount of retina ready applications don't impress me either. I will also need a optical drive for school but that isn't a huge factor. The iPad is a toy, but a very useful one. Ebooks are cheaper than textbooks, and once you start taking your iPad to the bathroom with you, it's hard to imagine not having one.

If you do any video or photo editing maybe the retina display will be worth it.
 
It always makes me laugh when people hate on the lack of upgradability on the new MBP. Aside from throwing an SSD in straight away, and upping the RAM, which are both things you do initially btw, its a non-issue for the majority of users.

Fair enough if you still use crappy mechanical drives (pointless given how dirt cheap SSDs are now), but in reality chances are you will never have to open up your MacBook after the initial upgrade.

My 7 year old iBook G4 is testament to that.

Dirt cheap? Are you kidding? a 500gb drive is still 400$+ thats is not dirt cheap. When they get to the price of regular HD's then you can say they are dirt cheap.
 
It always makes me laugh when people hate on the lack of upgradability on the new MBP. Aside from throwing an SSD in straight away, and upping the RAM, which are both things you do initially btw, its a non-issue for the majority of users.

Fair enough if you still use crappy mechanical drives (pointless given how dirt cheap SSDs are now), but in reality chances are you will never have to open up your MacBook after the initial upgrade.

My 7 year old iBook G4 is testament to that.

what about the battery, ive read the batterys are glued into the retina macbook pro
 
what about the battery, ive read the batterys are glued into the retina macbook pro

Covered under applecare up to 1000 cycles. Chances are you wont get anywhere near that with this being a desktop replacement.

If you manage to though, its around $200 to get it replaced by Apple.
 
Tough choice but I'd honestly stick with my current setup. I don't need a retina screen since I think my hi res is enough. The amount of retina ready applications don't impress me either. I will also need a optical drive for school but that isn't a huge factor. The iPad is a toy, but a very useful one. Ebooks are cheaper than textbooks, and once you start taking your iPad to the bathroom with you, it's hard to imagine not having one.

If you do any video or photo editing maybe the retina display will be worth it.

Dirt cheap? Are you kidding? a 500gb drive is still 400$+ thats is not dirt cheap. When they get to the price of regular HD's then you can say they are dirt cheap.

I bought a intel 520 series SSD 120gb for around 200 bucks, which id say is a tad expensive for 120gb but def notice a massive difference
 
Covered under applecare up to 1000 cycles. Chances are you wont get anywhere near that with this being a desktop replacement.

If you manage to though, its around $200 to get it replaced by Apple.

Are you talking about OP's specific situation, or are you saying that the rMBP is a desktop replacement?
 
While your budget may not allow a rMBP and an iPad3 now, you could always buy the rMBP now, and then wait a bit before buying the iPad3. I use a laptop and and iPad constantly, though, so for me I wouldn't consider not having an iPad.
 
Tough choice but I'd honestly stick with my current setup. I don't need a retina screen since I think my hi res is enough. The amount of retina ready applications don't impress me either. I will also need a optical drive for school but that isn't a huge factor. The iPad is a toy, but a very useful one. Ebooks are cheaper than textbooks, and once you start taking your iPad to the bathroom with you, it's hard to imagine not having one.

If you do any video or photo editing maybe the retina display will be worth it.

It always makes me laugh when people hate on the lack of upgradability on the new MBP. Aside from throwing an SSD in straight away, and upping the RAM, which are both things you do initially btw, its a non-issue for the majority of users.

Fair enough if you still use crappy mechanical drives (pointless given how dirt cheap SSDs are now), but in reality chances are you will never have to open up your MacBook after the initial upgrade.

My 7 year old iBook G4 is testament to that.

the computer initially cost me 1699 with education discount. with canadian taxes that brings it up to 1919.87 (god dam 13% tax! lol).

stock specs: 2.0ghz i7 Quad Core, 4gb ram, 256mb amd radeon graphics card and 500gb hard drive.

i had an issue with the macbook and apple replaced the ENTIRE computer for a brand new one and offered if i wanted to upgrade anything. so i upgraded the Anti glare screen for 100 bucks, no tax or anything.

the other upgrade I made down the road was changing the stock 500gb hard drive to an 120 GB SSD, intel 520 series, that was 199.99 plus taxes so 223.

The speck see thru clear was 49.95 plus tax so 56.44

the moshi palmguard was 30 bucks from moshi...i guess my as well work out the math now haha

1919.87
100
223
56.44
30_______

Total spent on macbook - $2329.31

for the retina, id be sellling my macbook for atleast 1500 and paying 560 extra for the retina. with that choice, would u say worth it?

----------

Are you talking about OP's specific situation, or are you saying that the rMBP is a desktop replacement?

i notcied...u ahve the top of the line of every apple product lol


While your budget may not allow a rMBP and an iPad3 now, you could always buy the rMBP now, and then wait a bit before buying the iPad3. I use a laptop and and iPad constantly, though, so for me I wouldn't consider not having an iPad.

i could sell my macbook pro for 1500 and spend the extra 560 cash on a retina.

but in total i spent around 2300 on te macobok,(upgrades, accesories)

wort the upgrade with that choice to retina?
 
i'd get the ipad if i didnt have one. i already have the 3rd gen ipad which i need for work anyway. sounds like you don't nor have you described what your usage is like. so you're just going to get useless responses that won't help you at all.
 
I sold my iPad 3 and my 2011 MBA in order to buy my retina. However, my situation had the added reason of wanting a larger screen. If I had an antiglare 15" MBP and an iPad 3 I would not have made the swap. I love the retina but do miss having the iPad.

Besides the MBA, the retina is the first glossy screen that has acceptable glare.
 
I sold my iPad 3 and my 2011 MBA in order to buy my retina. However, my situation had the added reason of wanting a larger screen. If I had an antiglare 15" MBP and an iPad 3 I would not have made the swap. I love the retina but do miss having the iPad.

Besides the MBA, the retina is the first glossy screen that has acceptable glare.

how much extra didu hvae to fork over on top of what u made selling both things?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.