I mostly use a custom built mechanical keyboard both at home and work. I previously had a 2013 MBP and felt that was ok, but while the 2016 MBP I have now has more stable keys (less sideways wobble), the extremely short travel of the keys has made me mistype a lot more. They have a harder feel as you bottom out the keys so quickly and that can be tiring over extended periods of typing.
In short, it's not a good keyboard and its design seems more driven to get the laptop smaller than provide a better typing experience. It is not that far from touchscreen keyboards that have no haptic feedback.
Just bring HHKB with you and place it over the stock keyboard.![]()
I don't understand your post from today. If you just ordered the 2016 today how would it arrive in time before your 2 week return period is up for the 2015? Unless your picking it up at an Apple Store in the next few days. If it's coming from China it takes at least a week to arrive and that's if there shipping it the minute you order.Currently bought a 2015 a week ago and I just ordered the base ntb 2016. The best way to find out is to compare. I'm excited for the 2016 but not happy to be carry dongles around. We'll see how the two compare and then I'll decide which one to keep.
Hoping typing on the keyboard won't be too loud or too much of a transition form the 2015 keyboard.
Agree with this completely."How bad is it?" implies that it is bad at all. From a perspective of efficiency, this is one of the best keyboards on a laptop that you can buy today. The key clicks are crisp, and minimal travel means you can type much faster on one of these than previous MacBooks. The large surface area also makes it easy to type accurately with minimal effort.
I bought the first gen. 12" MacBook when it first came out, almost 2 years ago. I write professionally, and It took me all of 15 minutes to adjust to the new "butterfly" keyboard on that machine. Of course, at first, it was totally different from everything that I'd been used to before it, and so it took some adjustment. But very quickly I learned to appreciate the new design, with the wider keys and less "wobble". The depth-travel was a bit shallow, and the return-responsiveness a bit slow - but I got used to that and quickly preferred the new design to the old "scissor" type so much that I had trouble typing on any old keyboard or machine. I recently upgraded to the new 2016 MBPro (Touchbar, 13") - and in my opinion, they've only improved on the original idea in the 12" MacBook. The depth-travel feels deeper (even though it's probably the same) and the return-response is appreciably faster now. In my opinion, the 2016 MBPro keyboard is ideally engineered for writing and extensive typing. The keys and responsiveness are FAR superior to the old, traditional, "scissor" type keys. They are the perfect width, and the fact that they just don't wobble at all means that my fingers absolutely fly over the keyboard.
So - in short - I personally love this keyboard, and believe that it is a significant leap forward for writers. Everything else feels old and clunky.
I could say the same thing about the trackpad. Implementing force-touch instead of the mechanical "hinge" style of the old trackpads was totally revolutionary. Being equally responsive across the entire surface of the pad is a huge plus, as is the ability to adjust sensitivity, and the variable force feature. On the 2016 Pro models, it's improved significantly over that original 12" MacBook implementation, good as that was(is).
[doublepost=1483838909][/doublepost]
Agree with this completely.
My son has it for college. He's loving it.keeping 12" as well?
Hey everyone,
How bad or good is the keyboard on the 2016? I've ready a lot of reviews that say it's loud and difficult to type in.
Lisa from mobile tech reviews says you'll get fatigue from the short key travel after an hour. Can anyone tell me their short term and long term experiences with the new keyboard please.
Same here, when I tried the 2016 model at the store I did not like the keyboard at all, but once I got mine in the mail and I spent a day with it I have gotten used to the keyboard.I really didn't like it in the store. Got it home yesterday and was on it for most of the night and I'm actually quite fond of it. Felt odd going back to MSI. We'll see if that changes over time.